Middlemarch (Routledge Library Editions - George Eliot)

First, the print. The entire DVD appears to be overexposed by about one stop. The colors are somewhat washed out. It appears to be a poor transfer. I have watched another copy and it has the same problem. It is not a horrible problem and if you don't pay attention to photography you may not even notice it, but it is disappointing if you do.

As to the production itself, it certainly is interesting in many respects and a great deal of effort has gone into recreating the period. Unfortunately the same amount of effort did not go into dramatic pacing. This is a slow plodding effort with no clear direction.

If you like these period pieces simply because they are period pieces you may like this, but if you are expecting a brilliant print and a sparkling drama you will be disappointed.

Muy buena adaptación del libro de George Eliot: los cambios que experimentan los personajes, la representación de la época con sus discusiones políticas y religiosas, muy cuidada y bien actuada. Especialmente quienes interpretan a Dorothea, Casaboun, Lydgate and Rosamond.

I decided to buy this because of the reviews I read in this forum. I have never read the book Middlemarch but love the books and movies from that time period, ie: Jane Austin, Charles Dickens. I liked Middlemarch in a way but found it lacking. It seemed to drag on with little details to tie the story all together. Maybe if I had read the book before seeing the DVD it would have filled in the gaps.

Have always loved this movie. But I am terribly disappointed in this blu ray version. It is grainy. Where is the excellent resolution of blu ray? The dvd is so much better! This so-called blu ray is going to Goodwill. Please don't buy this. Get the dvd instead!!!

Do not waste your money on this DVD - the distortion will make you dizzy. What a shame that such a great PBS production was so horribly reproduced: my years-old VHS taped from TV is of far better quality than this DVD.

The story might have been compelling, but the blurry, out-of-focus, crummy transfer made it unwatchable. After 10 minutes I felt as if I had on a pair of someone else's prescription lenses. Avoid a migraine - read the book instead!

Although this BBC miniseries is not the top one we've seen, it still has its moments. Also, it's quite a bargain for 7 hours of viewing. To be sure, rich character development, beautiful scenery, and fine acting, are all there. But the story is very much a 19th century soap opera with many of the key characters acting in a self-destructive, petulant way. Middlemarch is a pseudonym for one of the midland cities in England, most likely, Coventry. The town has its country charm, but many of the inhabitants are small-minded and petty. Few characters are really worth worrying about, with the exception of the Garth family who will be noted further below.

The central character, Dorothea Brooke, is born to an aristocratic life, along with her sister Cecilia. Their parents died while the sisters were young and both girls are taken in by their uncle, Arthur Brooke, played by Robert Hardy. He dotes on the girls as if they were his own and tries to make them happy. Despite all this, Dorothea feels guilty for her privileged life and longs to do something profound in the world. Instead of marrying the next door neighbor, the dashing, young Sir James Chettam, she is attracted to an old fossil and religious scholar, Rev. Edward Casaubon, who is at least 20 years older than her. (Sir James marries Cecilia in one of the few bright spots of the story). Dorothea's life with Casaubon turns into a nightmare, as their marriage is never physically consummated. One reason for this may be that every day for him is a "bad hair day." Mr. Casaubon spends his time on vainglorious sophistry and religious wanderings and eventually dies of a heart attack. While this is going on, the young idealist, Mr. Ladislaw, Casaubon's nephew, meets and falls for Dorothea. We learn that one of the stipulations in Casaubon's will is that Dorothea will lose her position and fortune if she marries Ladislaw. Of course, this is what happens in the end and viewers are left wondering she didn't give away her estate first and then run off with Ladislaw. At the conclusion of the story, the narrator tells us that Ladislaw is elected to Parliament but doesn't say much more. We're left to hope that he and Dorothea had a happy life together after much disappointment and despair. Nevertheless, we're told that when Dorothea dies she is left in an "unvisited tomb." Who needs that?

Other threads of the story are equally soapy, as we are introduced to the young doctor, Lydgate, and his eventual bride, Rosamund Vincy. Rosamund is daughter to Mr. and Mrs. Vincy. He is a merchant and the town mayor. Son Fred is a disappointment to his family throughout most of the story and has trouble making his way in the world. (Fred is played by Colin Firth's younger brother Jonathan and thus is the only connection we could find to the 1995 production of "Pride and Prejudice." After getting depressed watching "Middlemarch," we just had to re-view segments of P & P.) Fred is befriended by Mr. Caleb Garth, father of Mary Garth, Fred's love interest. Mary won't accept marrying Fred until he learns how to make a respectable living which he eventually does as apprentice to her father. They manage some of the local farms and estates and do well. Fred and Mary eventually end up together which is about the only trace of a happy ending this long story provides.

Back to Dr. Lydgate, he is also an idealist and donates his time in building up a big, new hospital in Middlemarch. He hopes to make the hospital a major center for the study and cure of fevers of all types. In his private practice, Lydgate does much to upset the existing social structure and becomes unpopular with most of the local power brokers. An example of this is where Lydate suggests a glass of wine for one of the locals rather than a concoction from an older doctor. (At this stage, viewers may be tempted to reach for a bottle of wine or something stronger, too.) Lydgate does gain support from Mr. Nicholas Bulstrode who becomes his friend and patron. Sadly, Bulstrode, the banker, makes important enemies and brings Lydgate down with him. At the end of the story, we're told that Lydgate dies at age 50, and Rosamund re-marries an elder physician. So much for idealism.

We've never had much interest in George Eliot and doubt we will pursue any of her other works. If they're like "Middlemarch," about the only conclusion one might have is that it sure is better living today, with all our problems, than having lived 200 years ago in a sad place like Middlemarch. If you want to immerse yourself in British period drama from the 1800's that has real punch and a happy ending, try "North and South."

As much as I love and admire El Greco, I don't prefer movies with elongated men and women in every scene. I am giving this one star because the transfer to DVD is so awful. It is really distracting to watch as everything is narrowed and elongated. The result is that it looks as if what you are seeing as been stretched and turned slightly to the side so that nothing is realistically proportioned. I could only watch about fifteen minutes of the movie before having to turn it off. I am sure it is a wonderful movie with great acting, but I won't be able to tell until I watch the VHS version, I suppose.

If you want to see suffering, on top of boring, on top of martyrdom without doing much good - this movie's for you. If you're otherwise looking for entertainment, then look elsewhere because all this movie will do is to waste your valuable time and regret ever having bought this movie in the first place.

Couldn't wait to be over. Characters are ridiculous and frankly, repulsive excuses for human beings. I hoped it developed the love story of the two main characters better and not wasted the majority of the film with the rest of them.

Eliot was an important writer, especially for her time. But we're talking a very long time ago. The style is of course antiquated, but that's expected. It's the content that drags this gigantic book into a long snoring nap. For example, in the first 100 pages we are treated to a woman who is overly religious and wants to marry the wrong man. Then she does. That's it. 100 pages. It goes on from there.

A remarkable rendition of Eliot's novel. I can't help but let my admiration of Eliot's work color this
review. "Middlemarch" is such an exceptional piece of literature that any half-way true rendition
of it would garner accolades from the storyline alone. Luckily, this version was well above half-way.
It was superb. The acting was superlative--even characters such as Rosamond Vincy were rendered
with such subtle nuances that what might easily have been a mere caricature, became a real individual
with much we could relate to. The same can be said for virtually every character, and I must give
credit to the actors for this. There was not a single primary character that did not draw our sympathy
in some way.

The settings and costuming were more than sufficient to keep us firmly in time and place. The
direction, cinematography and music were all of that excellent sort that keeps its presence unnoticed
though it is responsible for so much.

I am a great lover of literature, and tend to be hard and over-critical of movies that I believe foul or
distort the original work. Likewise, I will not stint my praise of those productions which manage to
capture the essence of the source from which it is drawn. And this one does. I daresay Ms. Evans
would be quite pleased with it.

What a complex well-woven story about life. George Eliot's works are incredibly good depictions of life, the challenges people face, what brings out the best and worst in people and how they cope with it, with conscience or without. Social issues of the time, class, economics, religion, women's limitations as well as men's, historical events and their effects on people and life are all woven in as well. There are some really great lines several of the characters deliver. Great cast, many of them longtime British character actors, and the leads are all excellent. The time is taken in the mini-series to depict life in rural England in 1930s. Impressions of what seem like the stories of real people will stay with me, I found myself rooting for all of them to find their way, to help each other. There's lovely character development, plot twists, romance among the stringencies of being proper, soul-searching, and plenty of things going on to keep the interest going. The book must be as much a classic as this series is. The author herself led quite a daring life in her time, and her feel for the things that come up in a relationship is well depicted.

An historic march to the new middle class and beyond, predicting brilliantly the current age. At the opening, a perfectly symmetrical classical arch frames a doorway in the background. We begin in the old society: God is not yet "dead" so mythologies are carefully analyzed for pathways to him, which of course is to the inner self. But science and research take over, symbolized by the Doctor. He fails in his best goals, pulled down by his wife, symbol of the new rigid bourgeois. Meanwhile a romantic theme arises in the musical artist, Ladislaw and his open countryside, sunlight and emotion. By this new, humanistic vantage point, we see the towering figure of Aquinas misty in the classical past. These a just bits of a symbolism-packed historical film based on one of the most important books to properly portray the leap from agrarian culture to the modern era and how it occured. All that woven into realistic love stories. Multi-faceted, rich, fascinating. Did we come too far!?

I liked most of the characters in this old era series. I didn't like Dr. Lydgate's wife, Rosamond, because she was a selfish woman who only thought of herself. No support to her husband at all & the ruination of him with all her debts & never supporting his good cause of. helping people. I thought he should have been married to the only good lady who tried to help others. Perfect match there. I didn't like Rufus Sewell's character with her. He was much better matched to Dr. Lydgate's selfish wife. Good story & I do love all the BBC episodes. More focus should have been put on the blackmailer & how he knew information to blackmail. Loved the beautiful countryside setting, watch this for that as much as the story itself.

There are so many 'main' characters in Middlemarch, it's like a soap opera, but none of it is over-the-top or filler. I quickly chose the storyline for Rosie as my favorite, wondering what would happen to their debt issues, her feeling of being ruined in her home town. I also enjoyed the story of Dorethea, and wondered how her marriage to a man who looked like a walking, balding skeleton would work out. That storyline left me a little wanting, as the relationships Dorethea built and the lives she touched was not built up in enough, even for this long, long series.

The costumes and settings and little knick-knacks were right on par. The horses, beautiful. The accents, for the most-part, seemed authentic.

Now for me, Thomas Hardy stole every scene he was in. You might know him from All Creatures Great and Small! He played Sigfried and in MM was just as bouncy and spoke with that outlandish air we all love from ACGAS. He was a delight and I wish he had been in it even more.

The beginning was a bit confusing, as they introduced all the characters (pretty much) right off and all of their names were too much for me. It turns out I followed along just fine and for good or bad, every character they had introduced right in the beginning was important. So don't watch this when you are sleepy or trying to do something else. No multitasking during MM.

Overall the movie left me feeling melancholy but that I had seen something well-done. Also, while the scenery and so forth was always beautiful, it was a little washed out, possibly due to the age of the movie.

If you enjoy movies like Bleak House (one of my favorites, be sure to see it!) and Pride and Prejudice, give Middlemarch a chance. Have fun!

After I started watching this series, I realized I had seen it before many years ago, probably when it was a Masterpiece Theater presentation. I liked this just fine. I haven't read the book, though I own it and have been meaning to read it. I must confess that I didn't like the character Ladislaw, though I couldn't tell you why. Clearly he is one of the characters you are supposed to like, but I just couldn't manage it. On the other hand, I really liked Rosanund Vincy. She is a shallow creature like you often see in period dramas, but what came through wa that she really loved Dr. Lydgate.

There are a lot of subplots here and most of them re handled pretty well. Still, in watching the show, I had this feeling that a lot was being left out as far as depth is concerned, which isn't surprising considering the length of the book. Clearly I will want to read it now.

There is what is called a feature that comes with the DVD. It is referred to as a reader's guide, and that is exactly what it is. Usually a behind the scenes documentary has interviews with the actors or crew, or deleted scenes, and so on. This DVD talks almost entirely about the book and the author, and merely shows scenes from the program to illustrate its points. It is almost like they filmed the feature separately and then used post-production to weave it into the series.

So this isn't what I would call a stunning or vibrant adaption of a classic novel, but it is entertaining and I would recommend it to anyone who likes periods dramas.

This is a superb adaptation of George Elliot's novel of the same name. Set in nineteenth century England in the rural town of Middlemarch, it follows the lives of several of its inhabitants, as the threads of their lives intertwine with those of others. Filled with memorable characters with whom the viewer becomes engrossed over the six hours that the series runs, it is a well acted, beautifully filmed period piece.

When an idealistic, ambitious, handsome gentleman, Dr. Tertius Lydgate (Douglas Hodge), moves to Middlemarch with the expectation of running a charity hospital that will allow him the opportunity for medical research, he is teeming with anticipation at his prospects in this provincial backwater. He is quickly thrust into a situation not of his own making, however, as the town seems to be a family divided over who is to be chaplain of the hospital. Aligning himself with his benefactor, Mr. Bulstrode (Peter Jeffrey), the town's unpopular banker, he sets the path upon which he must travel. Moreover, when he freely states his opinions without regard for the existing medical establishment, he makes enemies without even realizing it, so pure of heart is he. Upon meeting the lusciously lovely and thoroughly spoiled social climber, Rosalind Vincy (Trevyn McDowell), daughter of the town's upstart mayor, he is lost to her charms and loses sight of the prize. He sets upon yet another path that will bring him ignominy.

The lovely and intelligent Dorothea Brooke (Juliet Aubrey) is a scion of one of the wealthy first families of Middlemarch. She, too, is idealistic and wants to leave her mark on the world. Her head filled with socialist ideas, she, being pure of heart, longs to set right wrongs perpetrated upon the poor by the wealthy landowners, a class of which she is a member. Moreover, having been denied the education available to men, she deeply admires learning in others. Unfortunately, she is taken in by the scholarly pretensions of a wealthy, middle aged cleric, the Rev. Casaubon (Patrick Malahide), and chooses to marry him over her other suitor. Thinking that she can assist her husband with his scholarly work, she discovers too late that he may have other ideas on this matter. When she meets his cousin, the romantically handsome Will Ladislaw (Ruffin Sewell), this sets into motion a future event that is to have a lasting impact on Dorothea.

One would think that Dorothea and Tertius would be a perfect love match. Alas, that is not to be, as the heart of each is captured by another. Scandals, romance, intrigues, politcs, and the wind of social change permeate this epic period piece. With numerous memorable characters and subplots that move the story along, the viewer remains enthralled, as the entire six hours melt away. With beautiful, lush cinematography, wonderful costumes, and ensemble acting that makes this epic period piece flow, this film is a welcome addition to one's collection. Bravo!

This is a superb adaptation of George Elliot's novel of the same name. Set in nineteenth century England in the rural town of Middlemarch, it follows the lives of several of its inhabitants, as the threads of their lives intertwine with those of others. Filled with memorable characters with whom the viewer becomes engrossed over the six hours that the series runs, it is a well acted, beautifully filmed period piece.

When an idealistic, ambitious, handsome gentleman, Dr. Tertius Lydgate (Douglas Hodge), moves to Middlemarch with the expectation of running a charity hospital that will allow him the opportunity for medical research, he is teeming with anticipation at his prospects in this provincial backwater. He is quickly thrust into a situation not of his own making, however, as the town seems to be a family divided over who is to be chaplain of the hospital. Aligning himself with his benefactor, Mr. Bulstrode (Peter Jeffrey), the town's unpopular banker, he sets the path upon which he must travel. Moreover, when he freely states his opinions without regard for the existing medical establishment, he makes enemies without even realizing it, so pure of heart is he. Upon meeting the lusciously lovely and thoroughly spoiled social climber, Rosalind Vincy (Trevyn McDowell), daughter of the town's upstart mayor, he is lost to her charms and loses sight of the prize. He sets upon yet another path that will bring him ignominy.

The lovely and intelligent Dorothea Brooke (Juliet Aubrey) is a scion of one of the wealthy first families of Middlemarch. She, too, is idealistic and wants to leave her mark on the world. Her head filled with socialist ideas, she, being pure of heart, longs to set right wrongs perpetrated upon the poor by the wealthy landowners, a class of which she is a member. Moreover, having been denied the education available to men, she deeply admires learning in others. Unfortunately, she is taken in by the scholarly pretensions of a wealthy, middle aged cleric, the Rev. Casaubon (Patrick Malahide), and chooses to marry him over her other suitor. Thinking that she can assist her husband with his scholarly work, she discovers too late that he may have other ideas on this matter. When she meets his cousin, the romantically handsome Will Ladislaw (Ruffin Sewell), this sets into motion a future event that is to have a lasting impact on Dorothea.

One would think that Dorothea and Tertius would be a perfect love match. Alas, that is not to be, as the heart of each is captured by another. Scandals, romance, intrigues, politcs, and the wind of social change permeate this epic period piece. With numerous memorable characters and subplots that move the story along, the viewer remains enthralled, as the entire six hours melt away. With beautiful, lush cinematography, wonderful costumes, and ensemble acting that makes this epic period piece flow, this film is a welcome addition to one's collection. Bravo!

George Eliot is one of my favorite authors of English literature, and my favorite of her novels is Middlemarch. This 1994 BBC adaptation of Middlemarch is well-cast. Douglas Hodge plays Lydgate, a doctor who arrives in the provincial town of Middlemarch intent on setting up a new hospital. Juliet Aubrey portrays Dorothea, a strong-willed and independent minded woman who is determined to improve lives. When these two young people collide, their lives change in a manner that they had never envisioned. This adaptation, thanks to an excellent script by Andrew Davies (who also penned the script for the glorious 1995 adaptation of Pride and Prejudice starring Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle) and the great cast, bring the life of a town on the brink of the Industrial Revolution to vivid life. There's also strong performances by Rufus Sewell, Patrick Malahide, etc. `Middlemarch' never plods but engages the viewer's interest with its sense of realism and romance. As a fan of the novel, I was greatly pleased by this adaptation.

A good study of small town life in 19th century England. Several themes (marriage, class, gender, finances) are explored. Considered to be Eliot’s best work. Personally, I prefer ‘Silas Marner,’ but that’s a matter of taste. ‘Middlemarch’ boasts some fine actors, not the least of which is Patrick Malahide.

After enjoying Winston Grahams' Poldark, and Downton Abby, I searched the store for other period dramas. This series, Middlemarch, is as good as any you will see. Excellent acting with complex characters. I also enjoyed the struggles of society moving into the industrial age and the challenging of class boundaries. If you like period drama, good acting and directing, you will enjoy this movie.

George Eliot is one of my favorite authors of English literature, and my favorite of her novels is Middlemarch.
This 1994 BBC adaptation of Middlemarch is well-cast. Douglas Hodge plays Lydgate, a doctor who arrives in the provincial town of Middlemarch intent on setting up a new hospital. Juliet Aubrey portrays Dorothea, a strong-willed and independent minded woman who is determined to improve lives. When these two young people collide, their lives change in a manner that they had never envisioned. This adaptation, thanks to an excellent script by Andrew Davies (who also penned the script for the glorious 1995 adaptation of Pride and Prejudice starring Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle) and the great cast, bring the life of a town on the brink of the Industrial Revolution to vivid life. There's also strong performances by Rufus Sewell, Patrick Malahide, etc. `Middlemarch' never plods but engages the viewer's interest with its sense of realism and romance. As a fan of the novel, I was greatly pleased by this adaptation.

George Eliot (1819-1880) was a brilliant Victorian intellectual whose novels were written for adults. In this marvelous BBC series we see her words come to vibrant life!

Middlemarch unlocks the secrets of the inhabitants of a town

in the 1830s in the English Midlands. Industrialization in the

form of the railroad; the Reform Bill; the changes in the medical profession are all manifest in this series. Middlemarch is beautifully filmed with outstanding actors such as Juliet

Aubrey and Rufus Sewell makiing the characters come alive.

The story deals with three principal characters:

Dr. Lydgate who marries poorly and lives to regret it as he

courts and wins the shallow, vain and money grubbing Rosamund

Vincy.

Dorothea Brooks is the rich woman who marries a pedant but is

loved by his cousin Will Ladislaw.

Fred Vincy loves Mary Garth but has problems with gambling and

debt. Fred is the brother of Rosy.

The novel also delves into the unsavoury past of Mayor Nick

Bulstrode whose past is revealed by the visit of the awful Mr.

Raffles who knew him back when!

Middlemarch is seven hours long and first ran in the USA on

Masterpiece Theatre. The pace is leisurely and slow for many

American viewers used to quicker action. However, this BBC

adaption is well worth the time as it explores character in

depth; tells a classic tale with superb actors. The costuming

is realistic and accurate to the period. The music is dramatic

and the story told is classic.

I highly recommend this exquisite production! Excellent!

This is a superb adaptation of George Elliot's novel of the same name. Set in nineteenth century England in the rural town of Middlemarch, it follows the lives of several of its inhabitants, as the threads of their lives intertwine with those of others. Filled with memorable characters with whom the viewer becomes engrossed over the six hours that the series runs, it is a well acted, beautifully filmed period piece.

When an idealistic, ambitious, handsome gentleman, Dr. Tertius Lydgate (Douglas Hodge), moves to Middlemarch with the expectation of running a charity hospital that will allow him the opportunity for medical research, he is teeming with anticipation at his prospects in this provincial backwater. He is quickly thrust into a situation not of his own making, however, as the town seems to be a family divided over who is to be chaplain of the hospital. Aligning himself with his benefactor, Mr. Bulstrode (Peter Jeffrey), the town's unpopular banker, he sets the path upon which he must travel. Moreover, when he freely states his opinions without regard for the existing medical establishment, he makes enemies without even realizing it, so pure of heart is he. Upon meeting the lusciously lovely and thoroughly spoiled social climber, Rosalind Vincy (Trevyn McDowell), daughter of the town's upstart mayor, he is lost to her charms and loses sight of the prize. He sets upon yet another path that will bring him ignominy.

The lovely and intelligent Dorothea Brooke (Juliet Aubrey) is a scion of one of the wealthy first families of Middlemarch. She, too, is idealistic and wants to leave her mark on the world. Her head filled with socialist ideas, she, being pure of heart, longs to set right wrongs perpetrated upon the poor by the wealthy landowners, a class of which she is a member. Moreover, having been denied the education available to men, she deeply admires learning in others. Unfortunately, she is taken in by the scholarly pretensions of a wealthy, middle aged cleric, the Rev. Casaubon (Patrick Malahide), and chooses to marry him over her other suitor. Thinking that she can assist her husband with his scholarly work, she discovers too late that he may have other ideas on this matter. When she meets his cousin, the romantically handsome Will Ladislaw (Rufus Sewell), this sets into motion a future event that is to have a lasting impact on Dorothea.

One would think that Dorothea and Tertius would be a perfect love match. Alas, that is not to be, as the heart of each is captured by another. Scandals, romance, intrigues, politics, and the wind of social change permeate this epic period piece. With numerous memorable characters and subplots that move the story along, the viewer remains enthralled, as the entire six hours melt away. With beautiful, lush cinematography, wonderful costumes, and ensemble acting that makes this epic period piece flow, this three tape video is a welcome addition to one's collection. Bravo!

Middlemarch was often dismissed as of fluffy tale of townfolk of no particular consequence, not so, for it get's it's teeth into several hot topics of it's time. The story sounds gentile and ambling in an Austen style but is actually pacy and complex, touching on the hopes, dreams and dashed realities of many of it's characters as they try to find a way to live in within their social parimeters and subtle force/raise their own agendas.

This production is cracking and will leave you wanting, the costumes and period locating are spot on. Worth the six hours, you will doubtless get so hooked as to do it in one sitting.

Fans may wish to know that the series was filmed in Stanford in Lincolnshire, a beautiful Georgian/Regency market Town between Leicester and Peterborough. Stanford's local Museum now features a section on the series and the way in which the 20th Century was "erased" to make the period right.

This film presents Middlemarch and its characters as I imagined them. When I read MIDDLEMARCH now, I picture these characters in my mind. MIDDLEMARCH was written by Eliot in serial form. This film makes sense of the different plot lines and brings them together admirably into a cohesive whole. If you enjoy this film, and the novel itself, you might find the book MY LIFE IN MIDDLEMARCH of interest. The author has insights about the story I hadn't realized. Back to this film ~ it takes a complex story with many characters and unifies it. It added to my enjoyment of the book.

The story is quite interesting, but the quality of the DVD is lacking. I returned the fisrt one because it would just randomly freeze. We got through the second one, but it stopped in a few spots and we just skipped over those parts.

I love BBC films and was very interested to watch MiddleMarch.
What a disappointment to discover that although the characters are acted well, and the storylines had promise.... the film in itself dragged terribly.
Each time there was a promise of drama, excitement, passion, intrigue....it would immediately fizzle out - or to be more descriptive - the scenes and characters would never fully reach their dramatic potential either in words or actions. The moment was cut off, the feeling didn't come across completely - for lack of better terms, things would never climax, situation to situation.

Do not get me wrong, it was a very compelling story with different personalities of scoundrels and saints. Dorothea is angelic and steadfast, and although the scenes with the doctor and his spoilt wife were the most "fully" dramatic in his angers and their troubles - he is still a man to be admired for how much he tried to do for others and his marriage. There are several love stories/couples within the film - but again, none of them seem epic, heart-felt, deep or passionate.

I did try to be captivated by the movie - but one shouldn't have to try. It is a bit too slow, with not enough "UMPH" ; All the chracters were fairly developed - but lacked the connectivity to make you really care about them collectively or be suprised how things turn out.

This is a fine, absorbing six-part series, carefully plotted and uniformly well-acted, with fine visuals. The weakest episode is the last, when the various threads of this complex narrative are tied up in a semi-unsatisfactory way; but that's the fault, I believe of the original novel.

A warning that this single DVD, which compresses six hours of programming onto one thin platter, is of poor quality concerning the video (the soundtrack, rich in ambient stereo sound effects, comes off quite well). To squeeze it all in meant severe compromises, and the resolution of the image is barely at VHS level. But I was carried to the end, nonetheless, by the excellence of the underlying material.

MIDDLEMARCH, the film, is not exactly faithful to the book of the same name. Although most folks will appreciate the depiction of this tale, I recommend you read the book. The film would have you believe that Ms Brooke fell in love with Will Ladislaw the first time she saw him, but the book makes it clear that although Ladislaw loved Dorothea from early on, Dorothea (played bu the wonderful Juliet Aubrey) had no such notions and loved only her husband, the narrow Causabon (Patrick Malahide).

MIDDLEMARCH is a tragedy. Dorothea's greatest wish, that her life have meaning is denied her. First, she falls in love with a clergyman much older than herself and marries him against the wishes of many family members and friends. Then she gives up the estate she inherits when he dies, and with which she could have done much good. She is forced to do this because he has left a stipulation in his will that she forfeit everything should she marry his nephew (impoverished by the actions of Causabon's family).

Dorothea Brooke marries Causabon with the hope of assisting him in the development of his work entitled "The Key to All Mythology", an ambitions undertaking reminiscent of `The Golden Bough' developed by Sir James Frazier around the turn of the century (19th-20th). However, Causabon holds an attitude typical of his times - he believes women are not capable of scholarly pursuits. It is only when he is near the end of his own life, with his health failing, that he allows Dorothea to read to him and translate sections of the Latin texts, but it is too late.

When she marries Will Ladislaw, Elliot (voice of Judy Dench) tells us of Dorothea, "Her full nature, like that river of which Cyrus broke the strength, spent itself in channels which had no great name on earth. But the effect of her being around those around her was incalculably diffusive: for the growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts; and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs."

Dorothea's counterpart (MIDDLEMARCH is two books) is Doctor Lydgate, filled with noble aspirations which are laid in the dust by the profligate spending of his adored young wife. Lydgate wants to conduct research on Typhus and Cholera, and help the poor and ill with a new hospital dedicated to their needs. Dorothea wants to help him, but when she loses her fortune, their plans are lost and Lydgate must move to London and take up work that supports the lifestyle his ambitious and overweening wife clearly desires.

Acorn's DVD version of the film is well done, although not remastered ( I finally parted with my old tapes). The shots in England and Rome are much deteriorated since the early 1980s, so it may be worth owing the DVD if for no other reason than to have an idea of how Rome looked before automotive exhaust and ribbons of highway destroyed areas that had stood for thousands of years.

George Elliot was Mary Ann Evans, and Evans was a contemporary of Hardy. Both followed in the footsteps of Dickens and took up the cause of the folks disenfranchised by the Enclosure Acts, and in Elliot's case--the plight of women. This classic speaks to our times.

Juliet Aubrey and Rufus Sewell are wonderful as the star-crossed lovers in this miniseries. Juliet is Dorothea, an idealist who marries an old scholar, Mr. Casaubon, determined to make his life better and help him with his work.
He couldn't care less, of course, and their marriage is a cold one, until she meets his cousin Will (Sewell) who is as instantly smitten as she is.
When Casaubon dies, instead of being able to go to Will, Dorothea is stunned to find out that the evil old goat put a codicil in his will so that she will lose everything if she marries poor Will.
We also have the social-climbing spoiled Rosamond, who has enticed and married Tertius, the noble doctor who seems initially more suited for Dorothea, and Rosamond's devil-may-care brother Fred, whose life seems to be going nowhere.
I loved this miniseries, how Will pines for Dorothea and his heartfelt declaration is just so tender. Fred eventually becomes a man and Rosamond ends up getting what she wants, with poor Tertius meeting a fate he does not deserve.
Wonderful writing and wonderful acting make this miniseries a must-see.

I have watched this twice over the last nearly 10 years since it originally aired and started again last night. I was struck anew by how good this is - the evocation of the time and the situations of the characters. Such an excellent job of being faithful to the points Eliot was making about the matches (or mis-matches) of her characters and their failings. Love having it so that I can treat myself to something special when I want more than TV/cable offers.

Have watched this mini-series twice since I received it and I can sum it up in one word ... WOW! The character development, sub-plots, relationships and conversation in this, George Elliot's best work, are a feast for any BBC production devotee. The complexity of the themes in the book as well as the intricate relationships are well portrayed.

This mini-series is must viewing that satisfies the intellect as well as all the other senses involved in entertainment. Be prepared for a long sitting as you won't be able to tear yourself away once you begin the first disc.

The two star is for the poor blu-ray quality not the show that is excellent. I have had hit and miss purchasing blu-rays released exclusively in Spain and Italy. This is definitely a miss. The colors are washed up. The audio is too low. Those who already own the dvd of this show will not gain anything by purchasing this blu-ray. In fact, I am not even sure you can rate this as anything more than vhs quality.

Both my wife and I watched this production with hopes, but were disappointed at the conclusion. The film, while attempting to be comprehensive in its picture of connections in an 18th century British town, loses its focus, allowing its characters to drift and wander in and out of the story. If there is a main character, it is Dr. Lydgate, who does maintain some interest as he struggles with his disillusionment. The relationship of Dorothea and Mr.Ladislaw was just not believable. Perhaps better casting of the two would have helped make it work, but I am unsure. They never really seemed compatible, and their love story just did not work for us, given their characters. While there is a palette of interesting characters, none are held onto or followed long enough to really understand them. We tried to maintain some interest in the film, but by the end, it was just curiosity as to the outcome that kept us viewing. The ending, by the way, was unbelievable too--too contrived and too neat, in our way of thinking,for the 6 hours that preceded it. My recommendation: if you're curious and have some time to burn,watch it. Otherwise, watch Pride and Prejudice or Our Mutual Friend, they are superb examples of what can be done.

As most know, the book Middlemarch was written by George Eliot, penname of Mary Ann Evans Lewes (1819-1880). Although the miniseries is not completely faithful to the book, it is, like so many other BBC miniseries and other BBC programs we have seen on Masterpiece Theater, a marvelously well done story in its own right. In common with all true classics, it contains drama as well as comedy, tragedy as well as lightheartedness; it also has a large number of characters, running a continuum from the silly to the too serious, from the selfish and criminal to the altruistic and those with impeccable intergrity. The BBC has at its command a wonderful group of superb actors, and I detect nary a misstep in their performances. This is one of my favorite novels and this is one of my favorite movies or miniseries, which I have viewed many times. It always brings a pleasurable experience, even though the author, ever true to human nature, does not make a cheery, happy end to every plotline. I recommend the book to everyone who wishes to learn more of people; you will find people in the book similar to some you know yourself. I recommend the DVD for the same reason. It is a masterful telling of a masterful story.

This is an absolutely fantastic story and production. Of course, Rufus Sewell in his red velvet coat has something to do with that. Despite its length, I have watched the DVD numerous times and always with real enjoyment. The scenery, the colors, the costumes and the acting are all great. Anybody who likes the British period stuff will love this one.

This is the perfect film for Anglophiles or fans of well-made classic novel adaptations. Based on George Eliot's Victorian novel, this film introduces us to such memorable characters as sweet and sensitive Dorothea Brooke (J. Aubrey), passionate Will Ladislaw (Rufus Sewell), formidable Mr. Casaubon, handsome Dr. Lydgate, materialistic & pretty Rosamund Vincy, and her flighty brother Fred (Jonathan Firth), to name a few - as well as to their hopes, dreams, trials and triumphs. There are 3 love stories featured in this film (2 of them love triangles!), splendid characterizations, high production values and an overall wonderful miniseries! This is very highly recommended!

This is an absolutely brilliant adaptation of Eliot's novel in its psychological depth of characterization and 360 degree view of life in Middlemarch. What I don't understand is why people give it a low rating because they don't like the characters!!!

For heaven's sake, if you're not into 19th century literature, don't rate the movies: you don't know what you're talking about.

Not a faulty word or move in the whole masterpiece! What a cast: how does the BBC do it? There are some 90-minute flicks on video that I'd never give a second glance. But here's a SIX HOUR gem that I have already watched three times.
You know what? It's because every actor on screen knows what the words mean; they actually understand the script, and they behave in the 19th century, not as 2001-style posers.
This video could form the basis of a dozen high-school and college courses: history, sociology, faith, economics, politics. But it's best as a wonderful expression of the way people simply are. I love it. There are half a dozen stories happening, and you don't want to miss a moment of any. And, you begin to care deeply for everyone there.
Come on, what do you do with six hours, anyway? Watch this masterpiece!

I had seen this when it first came out and I remembered I had liked it then. It is set in the English countryside in the 1800s, you saw how the rich lived, how the poor lived who took care of the land of the gentry.

I haven't bought these tapes yet, but I've never forgotten Middlemarch since it was aired on PBS in 1994. I couldn't believe how I got hooked on waiting for the next one each week (and I missed three, so I've got alot to look forward to ;). Up 'til then, I'd always thought those PBS specials were just glorified soap operas (though I had enjoyed some of "I, Claudius"). But every once-in-awhile, over the years, I've vaguely remembered it and today thought, ''hey, I wonder if I can find that PBS thing on tape.'' I couldn't even remember the name. So I went to the PBS web site and hunted it down. When I saw the words ''Dorothea,'' it all came back to me. I wish I could be more specific as to why I liked it so much... I think I fell in love with Dorothea ;). Anyway, I can't wait to finally watch all of it. I hate it when PBS does something this good. Tax money used to fund PBS is unConstitutional.

Mr. Brooke, played by Robert Hardy, was the only likeable character for me. He at least had some range. Dorothea, the heroine, took martyrdom to a new level and the actress who played her, Juliet Aubrey, apparently is of the school of minimalist acting, i.e., she didn't do any. I had to keep turning up the volume to hear her because she whispered her lines, then her husband Mr. Casaubon, played by Patrick Malahide (who was much better as Sir Francis Walsingham alongside Helen Mirren as Queen Elizabeth) shouted at her so I then had to turn down the volume. There was no chemistry whatsoever between her and Ladislaw and after her husband died, I couldn't have cared less as to whether or not she and Ladislaw got together.

Dr. Lydgate and his wife Rosamund are just plain laughable. She spent money like a drunken sailor, then blamed her husband when they went broke. He, of course, was too busy undressing her both w/his eyes and literally to notice that they were out of money until the bailiffs came aknockin'.

The rest of the characters are insignificant and not worthy of comment. I gave Middlemarch two stars because the landscapes are breathtaking.

I recently saw this movie. The movie is good, but it can't be compared to North and South or Pride and Prejudice. P and P has always been one of my favorite movies, and I recently saw North and South, so I was looking for more movies that were similar. That is when I came across this one.

It was good, but I thought the story dragged a bit. I thought the ending was somewhat sad also, especially the story dealing with Dr. Lydgate.

I guess that is life.

If you are looking for a feel-good movie, I suggest North and South.

This is a wonderfully produced and acted presentation of the novel. I was not able to see the entire series, but what I saw was amazing. The pacing is wonderful, the characters are so well-portrayed, and the novel's text itself, as presented here, is fascinating. It has a kind of wisdom that is well worth taking in. I was happy to have taken the time to watch what I could of this presentation.

Four and a half stars really.
Different from most period piece movies in the fact there is a lot more politics, science, etc than you'd find in a Jane Austen movie. An excellent film overall, but with one huge flaw: the "climax" at the end that brings two people together in love stems from a very weak lovestory which I'm certain must have been done much better in the book. Although you are happy to see them together in the end, you don't really know why they fell in love and you don't really care that much if they end up together. Some great stories of tragedy that are done far better than the love stories.

Despite a previous reviewer's assertion that the book is always better than the movie, THIS movie is far better than the book! The turgid prose of the book bogs even excellent readers, while the movie (happily making use of the 1 picture = thousand words paradigm) entertains and enchants. It is faithful to the book and functions beautifully as the basis of any essays you might find due. My only caveat? Buy lots of popcorn.

This movie is a highly faithful adaptation of George Eliot's "Middlemarch." Others have outlined the plot, so I won't do it here. The only major thing that is left out is how Mr. Bulstrode is connected to Will Ladislaw. It was very well cast, although I imagined Ladislaw to be more handsome. Rosamond was just as annoying as she was in the book--she's a character I love to hate. For those concerned with content, there is mild swearing and a brief scene between two married people, but nothing is explicit.

From BBC comes another timeless classic. Middlemarch is so many things it is impossible to list them all! From love to politics, it keeps you inraptured in the wonderful story written by George Elliot. The story is supurbly played by Juliet Aubrey as Dorothea and handsome dashing Rufus Sewell as Ladislaw. This tale of forbidden love will draw you in... a must see!

George Eliot(Mary Anne)'s famous novel. Yes, the story is long and there are so many different characters which make people feel a little bit bored. But, it is a well made TV series. Persuasive actings and beautiful country scenes. I don't think anyone who loves 19th century novels should skip this one.

I waited so long to obtain a copy of this movie I was apprehensive to see if it was worth the wait. I am delighted to announce Middlemarch is 360 minutes of romance. It is a movie best seen all at once but if this is not feasible, owning it is the next best thing.
I was impressed by Juliet Aubrey's performance and was smitten by Rufus Sewell. It is a pleasant change to have a movie cause a sub-conscious smile.
The scenery was beautiful too!

This is a very, very good movie of her best writings, from our view. We first watched it, and purchased a VHS copy for our home in England. The last paragraph of the book sums it up well, and has been a theme of many of my speaches. It made me want to be a better person. As with most period movies, Americans must understand England and the British to appreciate it. Highly recommended reading, and the movie is as good as any could be from such an incredible book.

Reading all the great reviews on this production I thought this purchase would be worth it.
When viewing Middlemarch one can see that BBC spend alot of money making this. The customes are beautiful and the acting is great but one element of this well made production that spoiled it. The passionate sences between the town's new doctor and his beautiful wife.
Rent Middlemarch before buying it would be my recommendation.
This BBC production has nothing on other BBC productions.
Bring on North and South, Pride and Prejudice, Wives and Daughters,Bleak House (2005) David Copperfield (1999) and Our Mutual Friend.
Now those are worth your time and worth being added to your collection!!

This movie is probably one of the best period romances that I have watched...and I've watched alot! The wonderful costumes, and great acting, make this a wonderful addition to any one who loves period romances. A must see for any one who appreciates period romances!

This is one DVD my husband and I devoured. SO many plots and story lines all intertwined to make a great storyline. I have just purchased the book as I liked the movie so much.

I gave it four stars. I would have given it five if it had a few less swear words. They were mild, but I really enjoy watching shows such as "Pride and Prejudice" which keep crass language to a minimum. It is not as bad, however, as Vanity Fair. THe musical score was great which is something I always enjoy in these BBC shows, and something in which I was greatly dissappointed in "Vanity Fair."

This really is a captivating story and a well done program. Great price as well for the number of hours of enjoyable television.

This is the second time I have tried to watch this adaptation and have given up. I watched further this time to give it a better chance...through Episode 4...but I finally turned it off saying "Who cares?" The heroine, Dorothea, is dull, dull, dull and so is the hero, whats-his-name, though he is certainly handsome to look at. The doctor is predictably misunderstood, of course, fighting the establishment, when he has ALL the answers. He certainly is a lame brain in his choice of a wife. I wonder how he missed all of her expensive ways and tastes, before the marriage. He certainly overlooked her lack of interest in his profession and lack of intellectual ability. And we're are supposed to think he smarter than all the townspeople?
But what it comes down to, for me, is the dullness of the two main characters. I just didn't care if they got together in the end, or more likely, committed suicide...who cares?.
Oh I LOVE most of the Brit series; Pride and Prejudice, Vanity Fair, Silas Marner, whatever...I just didn't understand the praise heaped on "Middlemarch.

I rented Middlemarch from the library a few days ago and have already watched it twice! This movie is beautiful in every way imaginable. The actors and actresses to a superb job, the scenery is gorgeous and the score matches what is going on in the scenes beautifully! So how come the score isn't avalible on CD? I've looked for it numerous places and can't find it.
I highly encourage period movie lovers to watch this movie! You'll love it!

This movie was received quickly and in really good quality. It was excellent. I really enjoy Pride and Prejudice(the BBC version) and the Forsyte Saga. I thought that this mini-series was almost as good as those. I would recommend it to those who like BBC Drama. Even to those who don't like or haven't seen any of the BBC dramas, I would recommend this mini-series. It kept me guessing!

I watch a lot of the BBC mini series but was very disappointed in this one. There were so many characters (extended family members but what family?) and personally I didn't feel like they introduced them very well. It dragged on and then the end came quickly (when it finally came) and I wasn't sure who had ended up with whom in one case. Probably just me. I had seen that this was rated 8 1/2 stars but not in my opinion. I hope that means that North and South is rated 10 stars!!! Now that was good.

I usually enjoy period dramas/romances, but this one just dragged on. I kept waiting for the characters' lives to rise above all the sadness, but they did not. There was little plot, and not even a happy ending to make it bearable. I bought it based on positive reviews, but wish I had saved my money.

As a huge fan of period films, I was sorely disappointed with Middle March. I must agree with other reviewers who cited the problem with the elongated picture. It was so distracting that I could only stay with the movie for all of ten minutes. In this age of technology, it's difficult to believe that the DVD version of this film couldn't have turned out better. In summary the fact that all the characters were elongated and stretched to the limit, compromised the viewers' attention to the dialogue and the plot line.

I normally enjoy period dramas but I found this mini-series to be tedious. Particularly Dorothea...She is such a martyr!! Boring! She seems to want to suffer and the viewer is forced to watch as she shacks up with an old fuddy duddy who treats her badly. Whoopee, I'm having fun now. The doctor's wife is not much better.... He marries an insipid shopaholic who spends his money and treats him poorly.

I guess I wanted the series to be about characters I actually LIKED. These people were all sad sacks. 2 stars. Not my thing.

I tried 4 times to watch this movie and when I finally made it through it, I felt as though I had wasted my time. This has got to be the worst BBC production I have ever seen; and I am very fond of BBC. The story dragged on and on. It jumped around too much. The plot was almost non existent. There were too many characters that seem to be of no importance. I won't go on, even though I could. Save your time, don't even bother to watch this movie. It looked like it had promise but when I finally got to the end I discovered, I was wrong.

I've heard that this version of this period piece is top-notch; based on these reviews, I'd love to have the DVD, but it does not offer English sub-titles, so that lets me out. Too bad; another sale lost!