The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue

After hearing so much about GGTVAV and reading so many great reviews for it, I was definitely pulled onto the hype train. Luckily, the hype didn't fail me and I ended up loving like everyone else!

Monty doesn't make the best decisions (some of them had me rolling my eyes a bit), but thankfully he had Felicity and Percy by his side to keep him straight and help him out. I honestly don't think Monty would've made it very far without those two. He's also a bit conceited, but also super charming which makes it hard not to like him! Felicity is the voice of reason and even stronger than Monty when it comes to certain things. Percy is just a wonderful character in general. He faces a lot of struggles such as racism and ableism but he stands up for himself. He's also always there to support Monty.
Talking about Percy and Monty, the romance between them is just adorable. I shipped them so hard throughout the entire book. While GGTVAV is a historical fiction novel, it definitely has a lot of contemporary romance aspects.

While I'm not a huge fan of historical fiction, I did enjoy the plot of this novel. It was a bit overboard at times (like the whole pirate and sinking island thing), but it was a really fast, engaging read despite being 500+ pages.

Overall, I definitely recommend this to people looking for a fun romance novel!

I'm in love! I'm in love! And I don't care who knows it! In The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue, Mackenzi Lee blew me away with an outrageous romp through Europe and some of the most wonderful characters out there. Monty, Percy, and Felicity's trek across countries had the perfect mix of peril, debauchery, and shenanigans to make this historical fiction truly shine.

Let's start with these freaking wonderful characters! Monty, despite being an ass and a complete mess most of the time, is charming, funny, and cares so deeply. His voice is realistic, compelling, and pulls the reader right in. Percy may be the greatest friend of all time though. He puts up with all of Monty's crap but calls him on it every step of the way. And then there's Felicity; intelligent, absorbed by learning, and calm and collected in the face of danger. She's a force to be reckoned with!

In historical terms, Lee does 18th century Europe justice. From balls and operas to pirates and aristocratic villains, she clearly did in depth research. Especially in regards to grand tours, medical practices of the time, and views on sodomy and race. I'd expect nothing less from a fellow BA in History though. She also handles sensitive topics with extreme care and this ended up being an extremely diverse book in terms of representation.

Honestly though this book will give you all the feels!!! The romance is so angsty and Monty and Percy are ridiculously shippable. Every twist and turn kept me on the edge of my seat and there's just so much that happens along the way. I mean, who wouldn't want to go on a European adventure through the streets of Paris, across the open seas, and to a sinking island. I even loved the little hint of magic that propels the narrative and characters along.

Overall I abso-bloody-lutely adored Mackenzi Lee's The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue. It's such a fast paced, emotional roller coaster with tons of heart and I fell in love with these characters right from the start. The author handled the history and difficult topics with care and I couldn't ask for more. The hype is real people and I hope that everyone joins in on Monty, Percy, and Felicity's journey!

Originally posted on Hopeful Reads

Henry “Monty” Montague has one year left before he has to put aside partying and drinking and take over his father’s business, so he plans one last trip to tour Europe with his best friend Percy and his younger sister Felicity before they all start the next step in their lives. Even though Monty and friends have a chaperone and their year all mapped out, they deviate from the plan rather quickly. Instead of partying all the time (what Monty would like) or going to lectures and museums (what their guide would like), the three young ones end up on the run and even come face to face with pirates.

I picked this book up because of the hype surrounding it, and I’m glad I did because it’s great and I really enjoyed it. It was a little overhyped, so some parts did not meet my expectations, but it was still a fun book with a great adventure. The beginning started off a little slow and took a while to get into, but once I was about a third of the way in I did not want to put it down!

All of the characters were great, but Felicity was by far my favorite. She is smart, witty, and fearless. At the beginning we don’t know much about her because Monty doesn’t really know his sister, but as the book progresses the two learn more about each other and have a closer relationship. I absolutely loved Felicity’s perseverance. Despite the restrictions on women during this time period, Felicity wants to study medicine and become a doctor, so she secretly reads medical textbooks and sneaks away to attend medical lectures. Even though she is interested in a job she isn’t “supposed” to do, she keeps studying and practicing, and is a big help to everyone. Felicity is also fearless, not only is she studying something unheard of for a woman, she stands up for herself and Monty so often! There were countless moments where Monty wanted to hide or was too afraid to say anything, but Felicity was right there speaking up even if it was a dangerous situation. I was so excited to hear that Mackenzi Lee’s next book will be about Felicity, I can’t wait to read it!

Overall I really enjoyed this book, and recommend it to anyone who wants to read a fast paced adventure book.

Originally posted on bayyinwonderland.wordpress.com
I honestly can’t stop screaming about this book. I’m always wanting more LGBT+ books in my life but it gets a little stale when it’s always a modern day contemporary. Queer people have always existed and I’m dying to see them in other environments. Or other genres. This was a treat to say the least.

I’m the kind of girl that sits on her couch and watches every period drama known to man kind. I don’t know what it is about them. From the drama to the costumes, to the historical events, they’re everything I want. This book had everything I love about period dramas combined with everything I love about a good book.

Mackenzi sucked me in from the first page and I couldn’t put it down. As I always do with a good book, I devoured it all in one sitting. All of the characters were wonderfully fleshed out and there wasn’t a single character that didn’t have a purpose. One of my biggest pet peeves in a book is a character that is there for no reason at all or side characters I can’t connect too. Even though we see little of Monty’s mom and little brother in the book, they’re still fleshed out. We get little clues about who they are, and how they fit into Monty’s life.

This was a multi layered book, with more than one problem to solve. From Monty’s love of boys and girls, his feelings for Percy, his eventual return home to the adventure they get themselves wrapped up in, this book felt real. Each problem fit with the story and brought a new layer to each character.

I’m over the moon that Felicity is getting her own book. She was my favorite side character in this one. She was spunky and everything I could see myself being if I lived in this time period.

Pick this one up. Support LGBT+ books and especially ones like these. I’m not sure the actual genre of this one, but I would call it historical fiction with a fantasy twist.

So, what do you do when you have historical elements, a hilarious cast and an Indiana Jones-like quest? You get this beauty of a book! "The Gentleman's Guide to Vice & Virtue" (TGGTVV) follows Monty and Percy who are noblemen, leaving London for their Tour around Europe.

Now this is where the plot thickens! Monty is in love with Percy, but fears he doesn't love him back, they both have horrible families and there may or may not be a grand conspiracy concerning thr French Crown.
Add in Monty's amazing POV, which made me laugh more than once, and you have this little beauty. Honestly, I'm surprised there's not much fanart going around this pair!

And Felicity! A girl who wants to be a scientist, doesn't comform with the society she lives in and she wants adventure, even if it kicks her back.

I'll definitely re-read this, as also find the audiobook. Plus, despite the author taking freedom in some historical matters, there is also a nice detailed guide in the end of the book where Mackenzi explains all the historical tibbits, you may be interested in!

What a wonderful book! No high- or middle-school library that prides itself on inclusion -- nor any public library -- should be without it. It is a lovely book about young people developing love and competence -- in fact, growing up. Yes, it is nominally (1) about two gay boys (without being explicit ... I was prepared to squirm, but never did) and a clever girl, and (2) set in the eighteenth century. But more importantly, it's about fighting through the shackles of privilege and prejudice (but not in the way you think!) to cast off the demons (real and imagined) that bedevil every individual. And illustrates how 'that which does not kill you, only makes you stronger.' Perhaps the best part is discovering just how naturally all three main characters have been developing out-of-the-box solutions grounded in their personal strengths and weaknesses. I'm keeping my own copy, but ordering two more for local libraries.

Ah, boys. No wonder they drive us all crazy. Maybe I've gotten too used to wise-beyond-her-years leading ladies, because I was utterly thrown by this complete mess of a boy that is Henry Montague. Rake, scoundrel, and hopelessly in love. How do they even function?

From the beginning of The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue, Henry Montague's Grand Tour does not go as planned. Instead of a raucous year of drinking and seducing his way across the continent with his best friend and love of his life, Percy, they're saddled by his father's strict rules and a bear-leader keen on exposing them to culture rather than, ya know, "culture" *wink wink nudge nudge*. Thankfully, things get out of hand quickly when in Paris, Monty spitefully steals a trinket from the Duke of Bourbon that turns out to have untold value, and they end up on the run from highwaymen, captured by pirates, and seeking out a master of alchemy in pursuit of a magical cure for all ills.

Yeah, I definitely didn't expect the touch of fantasy that this book has. I still feel fairly confident categorizing it as historical fiction, and the fantasy aspect is period appropriate. I don't want to say it felt unneeded - because what is when it comes to fiction? - but it isn't exactly what I came here for. What I did come for was flirting, petticoats and lots of silliness. And there was plenty of that. There was even some very sexy make-out scenes. That said, despite the adult-leaning content level, this feels like its on the younger end of the YA spectrum. The narrative devices, the mishaps and misunderstandings, are on the goofier side, but somehow not goofy enough for me. This book is very much sincere, therefore its not going for camp, but what it nails emotionally it doesn't quite capture narratively.

The emotional weight was absolutely there. Our three central characters - Henry, his sister, Felicity, and Percy - all represent different sides of some of the more oppressive parts of their society. Felicity is a woman who wants nothing more than to study and learn when she's only expected to look pretty and make babies; Percy is a biracial black boy raised in a white aristocratic society who turns out has an illness that ostracizes him from that society even further; and Henry, the most privileged of the three, is a young queer man dealing with the endless physical and emotional abuse of his father that has left him depressed and traumatized. As the the three of them run for their lives, they also confront the secrets they've been keeping from one another and figure out how to accept and live with those secrets.

This book is difficult to rate for me, at least by the store typical star ratings. For me, it's a solid 3.5, but rounding up makes more sense than rounding down. I giggled, swooned, and overall found it incredibly easy and fun to read. That said, the plot meanders in some unnecessary ways. Personally, I think the pirates should have showed up way sooner. And Monty and Percy's constant waffling between passionate lovers and frustrated friends was both delightful and infuriating. Boys! What will we do with you? Monty plays just about every role in this adventure story - the dead weight, the hero, then the damsel in distress - and his growth, while frustrating when he stumbles, is actually very satisfying by the end. This book is exciting, sweet and light-hearted (except for when it decides to get a little heavy), it's aim just wobbles from time to time.

2.5/5 stars.

Read more bookish goodness on my book blog: Cal's Constant Raving Reviews

MY EXPERIENCE WITH THE BOOK:
This book was so hyped!!! I was ready for some fun adventures, and yes, there were some. But the story was ruined by the pursuit of the box/healing heart/undead woman underground. This confuffled the storyline and made it remind me of the mystery from Lady Midnight, but without the amazing Cassie Clare-ness of it all. This book dragged on for me. Nonetheless, I’m glad I can finally shelf the book as “read”.

CHARACTERS/DYNAMICS:
Monty: brush this guy was such a wannabe of any sassy historical figure from the Victorian era. He was... cliche. His sass was, at least. Monty’s features such as being a short (manlet) bisexual who’s been abused by his father, were obviously the promise and hype for this book. Which are great! Yay representation (but also: why can’t more people write about lgbt females? Why is there the hype, acceptance and thrill [AND FETISH] of gay male relationships, when there’s barely an ounce of the same towards females?!). To me, Monty reminded me of a sod. He whinges a lot, but also is quite snappy and demanding. But also; loves to make judgements on everybody around him. He’s irritating to me, and NOT any more realistic than the cookie cutter brooding YA Hero we usually see. He’s a two dimensional character with labels all around him, so people can applaud and go YAS REPRESENTATION YAAAAS MONTY, YOU GO QUEEN! -_- if you can’t tell; I’m not impressed.

Percy: this book should have been around Percy’s life, OR of the pirates. Percy had a much more interesting upheaval of events his entire life, without the mask of privilege like Monty does. The selling point of this book is diversity in an undiverse era. So why did we have to experience everything through Count Stale-Bread, and not the wonderful and tragic life of Percy? Maybe it’s my preference for books to explore this from the underdogs perspective. I strongly believe that this book would hold a greater impact if it were through the lens of the rich, educated mix-raced boy who suffers epilepsy AND is a lil gay (we never find out what his preferences are: simply that he likes Monty. This doesn’t exclude women or anyone else for that matter). Percy had such a complex rationale— they were on the hunt for the healing heart, but he didn’t want it. Never. Not before or after their journey. What was the process behind that??? We’ll never know. A character well wasted.

Felicity: I only read this book because I cared about Felicity, and her sequel (that’s coming out soon). She’s not portrayed in the most exciting manner at the beginning, but of course, this is because we are seeing it through the eyes of one of the most bland White Boys we’ve ever seen. I was disappointed her love for reading wasn’t actually romance and froofy novels, but it was enjoyable to see her anachronistic feminism take shape. I’m only disappointed because she doesn’t have a love for the arts… she has he passion for science!!! (And that, my friends, is inconceivable to the soon to be history teacher). Especially since this book is historical fiction! Don’t you just love when you’re reading a book, and one of the characters loves reading??? I was forming that bond, and it was ruined because she was reading MEDICAL JOURNALS. URGH! #Can’tRelate. I am excited to see her be basically Tessa from Clockwork Angel and see her beat somebody with her umbrella (like Jane in Disney’s Tarzan).

PLOT:
The plot was somewhat a fun idea. It’s the Grande Tour or Eastern Europe. Except, within a week or so, they’re out of food, supplies and money, yet somehow continue their journey. Maybe that’s why I didn’t enjoy it— those aspects weren’t very realistic.

I must say, it was funny leading up to the hijacking. Monty running naked around Versailles was priceless!

But then it turns just too neglectful to rational concerns and eh. It turned me off.

I wish the larger chunk of the book was based with the pirates. They were what kept me hooked to the end. Not silly France or Italy.

STRUCTURE:
1: pre-Tour, in England.
2: Boom, we’re in Paris (sudden transitioning is a major aspect of this book’s structure).
3: ?? (Middle book syndrome)
4: Marseilles
5: Barcelona
6: Venice
7: Santorini
8: all of a sudden two gay men can run off and start a new life together without money... sure.

THEMES:
- New Adulthood
- Progressive ideals including feminism, racism and the acceptance of LGBT lifestyles
- Travel

THE ENDING:
As I said in my outline of the structure, it ends with the two guys, one who is coloured, just running away with no money or credits to their name. They will live as a gay couple together and overcome: epilepsy, interracial relationships, and homosexuality, during the late 1700s.

Astounding.

But as Lee says in her notes— she doesn’t care if it’s achronistic. This is just meant to be a little fun. And I’m a sour puss who didn’t have fun so now I’m being a grump, sorry.

IMPACT:
I am going to read the next one, in the hopes that Felicity is more interesting. Maybe I’ll be able to relate to her better, which will further engage me.

The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue is a book that will steal your heart and run off with it before you even realize what has happened. Mackenzi Lee hit this one out of the park. Like clear over the fence and into the river another 100 feet passed the fence. This book holds wit and charm that will knock your socks off. It balances it off with serious topics that have just enough caring and concern around it from supporting characters. This historical fiction calls into play so many subjects that were taboo during that time era and does it with such elegance. Lee perfectly describes the life of a gay, white male, the discrimination against someone of color, and also the discrimination of females.

What I loved so much about this book and the fact was that it was a historical fiction novel, was that it did not overwhelm you with history. Henry Montague was the PERFECT main character. He was charming, witty, and downright hilarious at times. He took the typical path of finding his true self and being able to stand on his own two feet by the end of the novel, but the pure essence of his character spiced the entire journey up. I loved how Henry's, at time, eccentric personality was well balanced by Percy's cool, calm and collectedness. Between the duo's up and downs through the entire book, Felicity was there to add in a little dry humor and feminine touches. Felicity is simply a badass on all counts. I mean the girl sews herself together!

This book was so well done and a refreshing YA novel to appear on the shelves. Well done, Mackenzi Lee.

I give this book a 5 out of 5 stars.

*HISTORICAL FICTION WITH QUEER PEOPLE! This book has been described as a “big queer road trip through 18th century Europe” and if that doesn’t sell it I don’t know what will??

*It stars a bisexual English lord of questionable decision-making skills, his biracial queer best friend, and his asexual (confirmed by author) and bad ass little sister.

*It takes place in the 18th century and deals upfront with issues such as white privilege, racism, sexism, ableism, and homophobia!!

*This book is hilarious, fun, heart-rending, tear-worthy, swoon-worthy, and just too much goodness in one book! I may be a bit biased, but seeing a happy and fun story starring queer people is everything I’ve always wanted. I love how this book explores hard issues head-on but still manages to be fun and heart-warming.

*Definitely a must for fans of diversity, hilarity, and adorable romance!

Abso-bloody-lutely fantastic.

This book is like a giant happy swoony adventure escapade.
Monty is a fantastically flawed hero fighting both with himself in what he believes is unrequited love but also with his duty and what he actually wants from life. He fights with his duty to his name and his family, but also with his passion.

All of the characters were a delight and I loved every twist and turn.

The language was so on par. Lee's ability to take a historical time period like this one and keep some of the words and most of the customs while also blending it into today's lifestyle is phenomenal. This book is fun and hilarious but also throws a rope to a tradition I've heard of about the young elites going on their Tours before they take over the family business, I suppose.

All in all, this book was outstanding and I read it in two sittings - it would have been one if I didn't have to go to work. Psh. Should have called in reading.

First off, I’d like to point out that the author has a history degree, and obviously put a lot of research into her work; she even included additional information about the topics addressed in her author’s note. Anyone who complains of inaccuracy doesn’t know what they’re talking about.

The beginning is a bit slow, and the protagonist seems like, quite frankly, a bit of an ass, and while this is true, his character develops a good deal throughout the story.
The plot definitely picks up, I was drawn in and I could hardly put it down. I finished it in less than 24 hours.

This book is a beautiful mix of Belle (the 2013 film), Pirates of the Caribbean, and Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe. With a bisexual main character, his mixed-race love interest, and younger sister who refuses to sit and accept the role laid out for her by eighteenth century society.

I’m realizing that this review might make the book seem messy and all over the place, but it really is a very interesting read. It addresses a side of history that is swept under the rug, with well-crafted characters and witty dialogue.

It is easily my favorite book.

I cannot even BEGIN to describe my love for this book there are literally no words to describe its perfection GAH I’M OBSESSED!! You know how rare it is that I give a book five stars, and I literally would give this book 5000 stars if I could. It wins in literally every single element that makes a good novel. Character development, plot, action, romance, humor, writing style, realistic relationships, all 5/5 stars.

Let me start with the gorgeous, flawless writing style. Mackenzi embodies Monty PERFECTLY I literally read almost all of the book in a British accent in my head!! I have no idea how she does it haha. Everything just sounded so British-y I loved it. It was the perfect voice for Monty and I’m so so glad the book was told in 1st person because I want more time in Monty’s head with his thoughts lolz. The writing style just flows so well and is so humorous but also has all these gorgeous quotes that aren’t eye-rollingly prosy.

The character development is phenomenal. No character is really what they seem! You really have to keep reading to get to know the characters which I LOVED. Literally can’t even begin to describe how much I loved that. The more you go through the novel the more you get to know the characters, just like when you’re getting to know someone in real life! I’m not going to spoil anything in this review because I want everyone to experience it for themselves, but for real, Monty and Percy have so much more to them than meets the eye. Darker, more emotional elements that hit cha right in the feels.

This book also deals with sexism, racism, homophobia and more. Real issues that are so present in today’s world!! Gah I loved this part so much because one, it ties a historical novel to the present and helps us relate more to the characters and the world, and also because it adds a whole new element of realism and emotional impact. There’s a whole element in this book about loving people “despite” of something. Loving someone “despite” the fact that they’re black or “despite” the fact that they’re a woman, gay, etc. If you are loving someone “despite” of something, then you aren’t truly loving them. SUCH AN IMPORTANT ISSUE!!! Also, no matter what kind of life you have, your hardships and struggles are valid. Even if you’ve had it easier than some people in the world, your feelings STILL matter. Such an important concept and not one you see often in literature!!

I rarely find a book that I don’t get kind of antsy at the end wanting it to end, but that wasn’t the case with TGGTVV. I never wanted it to end! I want to see more of Monty and Percy but honestly, this was a perfect standalone. There were so many history tidbits, laugh out loud humor, like actually laugh out loud, and there was tons of action but enough downtime to really get to know the characters. I don’t want to give anything else away because I want everyone to experience this book like I did, with no expectations, but this book is fantastic. I mean, how often does a book get a perfect rating from me? Gah, so good!! The only complaint I had was Percy’s instrument it a violin or a fiddle???? Someone pls tell me because it changed every other line. But honestly this might be my favorite book of 2017!!

Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue by Mackenzi Lee is about Monty, Percy, and Felicity who are on a tour of the continent before Monty goes back home to learn his father’s business, Percy goes to study law in Holland, and they will drop Felicity off at finishing school along the way. But when things go wrong along the way they will all have to step up, and Monty has to do his best to not be in love with his best friend Percy. This was okay but I found Monty, the main character kind of annoying. He did grow up as the book went on and I did enjoy Percy and Felicity. I also really enjoyed the fact that it was historical fiction, which was reflected in different aspects of the story.

There are some books you know you're going to love before you've finished the first chapter, and A GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO VICE AND VIRTUE was one of those books for me. 50% quest-based road trip through mid 19th century Europe, 30% unbearably sweet love story between the protagonist, Monty, and his best friend Percy, and 20% coming of age narrative--or just coming into your own--and 100% delightful from start to finish. Throw in Monty's younger sister, an aspiring doctor who's far more badass than he is, a dash of magic, and lots of thoughtful exploration of racial politics and sexuality for good measure, and you've got a story that I haven't stopped thinking about since I finished it last week. I'll definitely have to check out the author's other books after this, because she's got talent.

THE GENTLEMAN’S GUIDE TO VICE AND VIRTUE was one of my most anticipated of this year, and upon completing it, I find myself glad I read it. I know that many people will love this historical romance romp.

I did find the plot of TGGTVAV to be incredibly action-packed and filled with numerous fun instances, along with a diverse cast of characters—Monty is bisexual and Percy is black and chronically ill. Finishing up this trio is Felicity, who was so lovable and adventurous that I was over the moon when I found out that the companion novel would be all about her. I really loved the banter between Monty, Percy, and Felicity, and the adventures really were highlighted with these three.

Do I recommend? I found these diverse characters made the plot move so quickly and while it wasn’t what I had expected, I did end up finishing this 500 page monster in two days. Definitely check it out!

I got this book in an OwlCrate box months ago and finally decided to read it. This book is a lot of fun! Full of major drama, a stolen cipher, an a trip around Georgian England, France and Spain! Monty is a spoiled brat taking a Tour before he has to return home and become an adult. His sister, Felicity, who would much rather go to medical school is being forced to go to finishing school, and Monty’s best friend (whom he is in love with) Percy, who is mixed race and going to Holland after the Tour. Touring the continent was a common thing for aristocracy to do during Georgian times. Monty reminds me of a younger Jack Harkness from Doctor Who and Torchwood fame. A lighthearted, enjoyable read.

I fell in love with the irresistible Monty within the first paragraph and Percy shortly after. Witty, sensitive and adorable these two precious and extremely shippable characters will burrow into your heart before the end of chapter one.

Fast-paced, adventurous, romantic and quirky The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue is also the funniest book I have read in a long time.

The diversity of the characters feels natural and a far cry from the run-of-the-mill ‘read me’ stories who force diversity into the story like an add-on.
@crushingcinders

I started this book and was so excited because it was different and smart and intreaging and I knew it was one I wouldn't be able to put down! It remained smart and different throughout. It was beautifully written and remained very true to the time and place even though Monty managed to be a relatable teenager despite living a life we can't currently relate to. I've never seen that done as well as it was in this book and i absolutely loved the juxtaposition. This was true for Percy and felicity as well, although I really wish, after 500 pages, that I knew them better.
The part that wanned, for me, was the intragung part. It started with that first kiss that backfired quickly and for no reason. From there it became one of those, "I should have, but..." "I wanted to, but..." stories as far as the romance went. I don't like "I should have,but" as the reason to prolong the romance drama which there wasn't much of after that first kiss. The story took a turn after key was acquired. At that point it turned into less of a coming of age romance and more of a treasure hunting adventure. Which, for most I'm sure was a great change of pace but personally I prefer the former.

This novel has so much voice, the kind that’s funny and unapologetic. I really do want to hug this book, which is problematic since I listened to the audiobook.

The MC is a charming rake who gets himself into mess after mess, and I adore the fact that one of the side characters is his sister. That’s so rare in YA these days…to have a really relevant character be a sibling, and for that sibling to go along on the adventure. It added a nice dynamic.

These teenagers were appropriately teenagery, and I loved how the dated time period still felt so fresh and easy to exist within. These are the kind of characters who steal away little pieces of your heart, and you don’t even mind.

Ahoy me mateys. It is time for this book to walk the plank . . .

“But Cap’n!,” me crew beseeches. “Why? Why must ye toss our beloved book overboard? Does it not have a wonderful title? Cover? Blurb? Please don’t send Monty overboard. We ship him and Percy! Please no!”

“Bah!” Says I. “It was all yer caterwauling about this novel with its shiny cover, rascally good title, and tantalizing bits of plot that led me to not only pick up yer recommendation but not abandon Monty at the first sight of him.”

“Aye, Cap’n! But aren’t ye glad to have met Monty and his crew? Monty is a sarcastic degenerate with a sense for fashion and fun. Doesn’t he bring joy and happiness to the crew?”

“Bah! The only happiness that ye should be carin’ about be me and mine good will. Monty may be fun to ye slobbering scallywags but to me he be impetuous, self-serving, annoyin’, whiny, unmotivated, and useless in times of crisis. Which he always seems to be the cause of. That Percy of his seems to be a jolly dependable sort and that sister of his be worth ten of each of ye rotten flee infested reprobates. But Monty. He ruins everything!”

“But won’t ye at least let them plead their case? I mean don’t ye think Percy and Monty deserve to be together forever? Aren’t they the perfect ship?”

“Bah! The only important ship be me own. Monty is goin’ to walk. Percy is a lost cause due to his infatuation with that useless guttersnipe. Their whole relationship be one bad trope. Percy could do so much better. And while I am sure that Felicity will survive and thrive, she goes where that despicable brother of her does. And as to her further adventures, I just don’t care.”

“But Cap’n! Won’t ye reconsider?”

“No.” :: splash splash splash::: Arrrr!

This book was just so much fun. From the very first page to the last I was completely entertained on this ride and it was one heck of a ride at that. I never thought any of these kids were going to catch a break. One of the things that I really loved about this book was seeing the relationship grow between them. I was fangirling over Percy and Monty from page one, but even after a while I loved seeing Felicity try to understand her brother more. The adventure itself was insane and I felt like everything was just somehow against them, but oh lord if it wasn't fun to watch unfold.

This book was nothing like what I thought it would be about. I thought it would be Englishmen in the Victorian era roaming and partying through Europe and having drunken adventures. It turned out to have mystery, real adventure, running from bad guys, highway robbers, circus folk, pirates, hidden treasure, etc. And the main character, Monty, is hilarious. Such a rake. It is a 500 page book and the adventure doesn't really start until 85 to 100 pages in. There was also moments that touched on racism, gender inequality, and homophobia that made this book a little more meaningful and deeper than I thought it would be.

I gave this book 4 out of 5 stars on Goodreads and the store.

4.5 Stars....I listened to the majority of this highly entertaining YA historical novel. The MC, Monty was ridiculously self absorbed, vain, and naive. Yet his love for his best friend, Percy, erased his faults and turned them merely into quirks.

This was a refreshing and fast paced story which took us across much of Europe. Monty accidentally pockets a ciphered key at Versailles and suddenly becomes a target. Along with his sister and Percy, the trio make their way to Spain, get involved with pirates, and sink an island all to reach an alchemical heart that will heal Monty’s lover.

A delightful read and a fantastic narration in audiobook.

THIS BOOK IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! It was one of my most anticipated reads of the summer and it did not disappoint. The story alone intrigued me, as I love Europe and I have traveled there twice. BUT what made it even better was the LGBT theme (Monty and Percy) and then a badass female character in the form of Monty's sister, Felicity (who is getting her own book!! ahh!!). The banter in this book was witty and Monty was just so sarcastic all the time it was hilarious. I can't explain enough how much I loved the chemistry between Monty, Percy and Felicity and how well they worked together as main characters. It felt like another HP trio to me because they were so fantastic! YOU WON'T REGRET PICKING UP A COPY OF THIS FANTASTIC NOVEL!

Got this from the library, where the cover caught my eye and dared me to pick another book. Hooked from the first page--by Monty's voice, by the promise of adventure & feats of derring do, by the whisper of mystery.

As many others noted, Monty's journey to humbled, loving, yet wit and humor intact young man is done well, with a deft touch. Nothing in this book hits us over the head. Not his gradual change, not his sister's desire for something beyond the restraints of her upbringing, nor Percy's tortured but never hopeless outlook on the future.

Well researched, well written, and straight into my heart. Though it ends just fine as it is, I wouldn't mind a second book to see how everyone is faring.

I went back and forwards with this one, sometimes really loving it and other times distinctly disliking the main character and/or rolling my eyes over to-stupid-to-live stunts that make no sense, other than being obvious bids to move the plot in certain directions. While I loved the narrative style and Monty's sense of self-depricating humor, I thought the whole thing got too ridiculous to believe by the end. The narrator however did a MARVELOUS job with the story.

Note: I borrowed through Hoopla. I chose to listen and review it.

A lighthearted romp of a book that is a genuine page-turner. It's the kind of book that keeps you saying, "Oh, just one more chapter before I turn in!" As historical fiction, the language and attitudes are often unapologetically anachronistic regarding feminism, sexuality, and race relations. Still, there are enough period references to give a feeling of historical accuracy to the created world. Despite the title, after the first hundred pages or so, there isn't very much vice (and no explicit sexuality). But it's nice to see defined, genuine characters with clear voices and personas and YA literature about the gay experience that isn't just a story of coming out.

I think this might be the type of YA romance that we will see more of, written by and for the millennial generation, and I have to say, I’m here for it! Though it is set in Regency England (and Europe, as the main characters embark on their Grand Tour), it to an extent anachronistically inclusive of diverse races and sexualities. I had a moment of GenX crankiness over it until I realized that no one (including me) is reading this book to get a detailed historical look into the time. It is sweet, flirty, swash-buckling, and just a whole lot of fun!

I personally wasn’t a huge fan of this book, though I give it three stars because it turned around for me somewhere in the last 100 pages. But it took that long to feel like Monty was actually making progress as a person and growing. Also, a lot of what happened to them seemed so coincidental that it seemed like Monty wasn’t the main character of the story. More like fate was just deciding for him to have these random interactions that set him on different paths. I loved Felicity and Percy, but felt like they were constantly having to teach Monty to be better and that Monty never respected this or appreciated it. I wanted so much to like this book a bit more, but in the end, I just didn’t.

A fantastic, hilarious, and wild ride from start to finish. I absolutely loved Monty with his flirtatious, sarcastic, and confident attitude along with his unflappable adoration of his best friend Percy. This m/m romance set in the 1700s was absolutely amazing, especially when it was paired with the action packed misadventures of Percy, Monty, and his sister Felicity. This book made me laugh and love the characters immediately.

If you haven't read this book yet, you should definitely pick it up! Also, the audio book is A+ if you're into that.

I love it! The writing is amazing, I'm a complete fan and I'm about to order all other books I can find by this author. It's really quite a feat when someone can make me tolerate a character like Monty, I really really wouldn't like him irl and it was hard at first, but after a while I did more than tolerate, I actually grew to like him a bit! And there were plot things that I usually hate and now don't, that's quite spectacular. And Percy is perfect. Love the fact that it had a proper ending, I was a bit afraid for cliffhangers when I saw that there was a second book coming. Though right now I really want to dive into it, since I have developed an adoration for Felicity as well.

"If the whole of England were sinking into the sea and I had the only boat with a seat for a single person more, I'd save Percy. And if he'd already drowned, I probably wouldn't save anyone. Probably there wouldn't be much point in me going forward either. Though I would hang on because I'd likely wash up in France, and from what I remember from the summer my family spent there when Felicity and I were young, there are some lovely women in France. Some handsome boys as well, many of whom wear their breeches very tight, though I wasn't clear where I stood on that when I was eleven."

The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue completely and utterly wrecked me. While half of the crying I did was probably a symptom of it just being that time of the month (hey, I'm being honest here), the other half was undoubtedly the doing of Mackenzie Lee entirely. The last book I read and cried while reading was Atonement, and that was because that book is incredibly sad. The Gentleman's Guide is surprisingly sad, and I was not prepared for it. But am I so profoundly happy with it? Extremely.

The book follows Monty, the son of an English earl, on his Grand Tour of the Continent, accompanied by his best friend - and secret crush- Percy and insufferable younger sister Felicity. Monty, however, is certainly the insufferable one. He's selfish; gambling, sleeping around, drinking- but he would do anything for Percy, who he is deeply and madly in love with. Only, it's the 1720s, sodomy is illegal and a sin, and Percy is half black. Also, Monty has no idea how to handle is emotions and conveys his love for Percy through painful detours around the truth, straight to reckless behavior instead. So there's a few issues, yeah.

Despite Monty's vanity - actually, extreme vanity- he is a wonderful character whose voice I could listen to all day and always want to hear more and more. He makes terrible selfish decisions, yet no one lets him get away with them. Especially not Percy. And have I mentioned how unapologetically gay Monty is? He's so gay. Actually, he's bisexual. And it's wonderful. While I have often seen bisexual characters written as overly flirtatious with every human being they meet, Monty is very flirtatious but not with every human being. Just the pretty ones. It's who he is, and his flirtatiousness is not attached to his sexuality. If he were straight, he'd still be a gigantic, sodding flirt. This concept is a bit hard for me to explain, but if this problem with the way other LGBT characters are written has ever bothered you before, let me assure you that Mackenzie Lee executes the book's gayness almost flawlessly.

I've read way too many books where there are gay (side) characters but there is such little chemistry and sensuality written for them that they might as well just be best friends, or worse, coworkers. Come on, people! Just because they're gay doesn't mean you have to take out all of the romance. Why should writing a gay romance be any different from writing a straight romance? Right- it shouldn't. Love is love. Need I say more?

So, with that being said, I can also assure you that this book is extraordinarily romantic. It put me in tears, that's how beautiful it is. Monty doesn't hold back any of his feeling for Percy to the reader, just to Percy... Which is painful, yes, but it allows time for the romantic plot to fully develop and not leap into things without much to go off of. It's frustrating to read this book as well because you can feel the entire time that Monty and Percy are head-over-heels in love with each other, if only you could reach through the pages and smash their faces together. They're the reason for my uncontrollable tears whilst reading. I will not reveal the fate of their love, however, I promise this isn't a tragedy.

What is tragic is a subplot that Lee really just surprised me with. So we have some racial issues to address- check, queer culture- check, European politics- check, and... disability? Yeah, that last one really threw me off, too. Now I'm about to reveal a big character detail that was never disclosed during any of the promotional stuff for the book, nor have I really seen anyone else address it since. So if you really don't want anything to be spoiled, skip the next bit of the review.

[I was as shocked as Monty when a quarter into the book, Percy has an epileptic seizure. Why hadn't anyone said anything about this? I think it's an incredibly important aspect of the book and of Monty and Percy's relationship, so I'm baffled as to why it seems ignored. I don't know, is it taboo? It shouldn't be. Disability shouldn't be taboo. We should be able to address is and discuss it for the perfectly normal thing it is. Not that epilepsy is any good to have, but geez, we can at least say the word. Epilepsy. Percy has epilepsy. I'm beginning to think that this important detail was kept hidden not for the sake of plot secrecy, because most of the plot is actually kept secret, but was actually not revealed because it might turn off readers. I'm not sure. While Percy's disability does have something to do with the rest of the secret plot, which I won't disclose, it's not so tied to it that it couldn't have been mentioned earlier, either in the book itself or by the author during promotion.

Although I'm perturbed that no one is talking about it much, I absolutely loved that it's there and that it is addressed so well in the book itself. It strengthens Monty and Percy's relationship and also lays the foundation for a much greater theme that comes later on in the book, which I will get to.]

The Gentleman's Guide has so many splendid things gorgeously woven into it that it's really difficult to sum it all up. We've got good ol' highwaymen, courtly extravagance, Monty admiring Percy's butt, pirates, some creepiness, a really badass female character who defies her time, pirates, and so, so much more. And guess what? This is a book about the 18th century in which not every single bloody character is white. So that's a hint to you that Percy isn't the only person of color (POC). There's also a lot of themes that come with these things, and most of these themes are actually quite deep. Besides the queer theme, I also really loved the "privilege" theme. Lee doesn't ignore that Monty, even though he is gay, is far more privileged than Percy and even Felicity. It's handled so delicately yet so bravely. I appreciated this tremendously.

Obviously I'm in love with this book, but here are couple of cons I feel obligated to address, since you can't truly love something without recognizing its flaws.
1) Monty is still selfish Monty at the end of the book. Sorry to spoil that, but it's true. He doesn't change much, however, he's put in his place a number of times. The way the book ends presents a way for Monty to change as he keeps growing, we just don't get to witness it. And now that I'm thinking about it, I'm realizing that maybe it's unrealistic for me to expect Monty to change everything about him in such a short amount of time, since I can hardly do that myself.
2) Monty loathes Felicity so much that we really hardly get to know her. I want to know everything about her! I feel deprived.
Ok. That's about all the negativity I can muster.

So, after not much consideration, I've decided that The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue is definitely my favorite book, probably ever. (Sorry, Persuasion :/ ) I just loved everything about it, and I wanted it to never end. While it's apparently extremely dear to me now, I will say that it's probably not everyone's cup of tea. I think LGBT fiction is still taboo among young adults who aren't actually a part of the LGBT community. So if you're not part of the LGBT community, the unapologetic gayness might bother you. Maybe just make you feel a little uncomfortable. (It's not called the "Big Gay Road Trip story you never knew you needed" for nothing.) But if you are, then like me you are just going to ravish this book from cover to cover.

Trigger warnings for physical abuse, specifically perpetrated by the MC's father, period typical racism, and period typical homophobia/queerphobia.

Ahhh, this book is amazing!!! There are some parts that are really hard to read, but it is amazing. I head-canon Felicity as aro-spec and/or ace-spec, and Monty is canon bisexual, even though he doesn't have that language because of the time.

I just really liked everything about this book. It's fun and funny but also serious and has a fair bit of inclusion and diversity that i noticed. Definitely a recommend~

I'd heard so many great things about this before I gave in and read it and I was not disappointed.

It tackles tough issues like homophobia, racism, ableism, and sexism head-on and it does it amazingly well and with a healthy dose of humor. The characters are all very well written, likable and exasperating and believable, and have great development. This is such a fun adventure of a book that I can't recommend enough.

*Spoilery note*
The Grand Tour is not as important to the plot as the synopsis makes it seem

I loved this book! I feel as though I could keep reading this book forever and it’s definitely the sort of story I will be able to go back and read again on a day when I’m feeling a bit down and need some cheering up. I think it’s a bit like Robin Hood Men in Tights... I know it backwards but it never ceases to make me happy when I watch it and the jokes never get old! I had a feeling I would like it from just reading the synopsis and was not at all disappointed when I did. It’s the perfect tale of unrequited love, Victorian sensibilities (and how ludicrous they are in today’s society), travel, adventure, mishap and misfortune, sometimes inappropriate displays of affection and cute moments. I was swept up in this so quickly and definitely enjoyed the wild ride with Monty, Percy and Felicity. Pure cotton candy cinnamon roll goodness

If you've ever wondered if an eighteenth-century road trip novel starring a bisexual teenage boy rummaging through Europe with his best friend and sister would be any good, THE GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO VICE AND VIRTUE answers with a resounding YES. The aforementioned Monty, Percy, and Felicity are three of the most engaging characters I've ever encountered, and the novel that they star in is simply one of the best adventure novels I have ever read. Filled to the brim with mayhem, chaos, and lots and lots of laughs, Mackenzi Lee's sophomore novel is not to be missed. (

I didn't know specific plot points before reading this, and if you had said that it involved highway robbery AND pirates, I would have thought this book was going to be over the top. But no! Mackenzi Lee manages to ground the incredible plot of the book into plausibility and hilarious reality, and everything just works about it. I really enjoyed the character's journeys, both physically and emotionally. The love story was romantic, swoonworthy, and dragged out in just. the. right. way. It's almost like Lee had a mathematical equation to provide the exact right amount of frustration without teetering into anxiety or despair. Would heartily recommend this book to anyone- if you're considering reading this, go for it.
The language was very authentic, both in dialogue and prose, while maintaining a feel for contemporary drama and relationships. The author's notes for what inspired her and the research she undertook for this book also add about four books to my TBR list. The Grand Tour! I'm all about it. xx

This book is profoundly, totally, almost manically anachronistic, which means attitudes, devices, and knowledge that don’t match the historical period. But its breath-taking conceit and effortless world building make this madcap adventure a more accessible Version of the travel novels of the past. More fun than Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas because it has characters who develop and exhibit human qualities. Who will star in the movie??

fantastic, funny, fearless - Monty's romp through Europe on a grand tour (basically study abroad before he has to take over the family biz, post-university) is FABULOUS. It is indeed a romp. I loved how saucy and sassy Monty was and I LOOOOOVE Felicity - so happy she's getting her own book. What I liked about Gentleman's Guide was that it wasn't explicit (graphic sex or anything) but more of longing wanting desire.... and also REALLY funny. Like laugh out loud funny. which you often don't find in Historical Fiction :-)

The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue is the kind of book you fall in love with from the very start – and not just because Monty, the ne’er do well protagonist, is such an incorrigible flirt. Simultaneously harrowing and hilarious, everything about this book from the serious questions posed about sexuality, chronic illness, and social inequality to the extraordinary (and sometimes piratical) journey Monty, his best friend, and his sister find themselves on make Mackenzi Lee’s latest the kind of book you’d be a fool to miss.

"Monty..." he says, my name sopping with dread.
"And," I continue overtop him, "I'd like you to both remember just how much you adore me and how dull and gloomy your lives would be without me in them."
"What did you do?”

This was one, if not my most anticipated book of the year. I have been watching this book like a hawk for months. Now, I'm going to be honest with you, I was nervous. SO VERY NERVOUS that this book wasn't going to live up to the hype. My dear friend, I was so very wrong. This book is abso-bloody-lutely perfect!!

Scream it from the hill tops, shout it from sea to sea my love for this is real and very alive. I love Monty and Felicity and PERCY I LOVE HIM SO MUCH GUYS.

If you love adventure, LGBT romance & good conversation, humor, shipping with both pirates and your heart. READ THIS BOOK.

Please for the sweet love of Percy and his fiddle go pick this book up and read it. You will have 0 regrets.

Also is it too early to beg for a sequel Mackenzi Lee? I think not.

One of the most amazing books I've read!

I happened upon this book in the Young Adult section of a book store. The cover caught my eye as i was putting another book on the shelf. It seemed interesting, so I purchased it.

I couldn't put it down.

There was a little something of everything in this book -- a gay love story, yes, but also history, adventure, pirates, mystery, suspense, humor, etc.

Why did it take me this long to read this?? I completely understand why everyone loved the story and adored the characters so much because both are brilliant. Incredibly fun, witty, and emotional. This was such an easily enjoyable read. I didn't want it to end and I am ready for the next book to see where Felicity's story will go. So happy that I finally picked this up!

I've never listened to an audiobook before, but by God is this a great one. Not merely for the amazing voice telling it, but for the words as well. This book is a beautifully, humorously written adventure romance and I was 100% here for it, for all 10 hours of it.

I was apprehensive to read (or listen) to this because I wasn't sure I could get into a setting without magic or space or other such things, I apparently forgot how much I used to love historical adventure-type books back in the day. It's like fantasy without the fantasy! And The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue's adventure makes a lovely background for its romance between our protagonist and his best friend. And my heart, y'all. My heart. This story took my heart on a whirlwind trip through Europe.

Five stars! And I'm already dying for the sequel starring Felicity because I love Felicity. Though I feel like we need the same narrator to just use his Felicity-voice or it won't be right (and he does some great and hilarious voices, seriously).

To echo many other people ,this book is an amazing story ...loved the characters and the timing of all the action . this book had silly, romantic and serious moments all played out in the dialogue of young people coming up against real feelings and problems /
I could only hope that Monty will be back in another episode of his life because he is so unforgettable and young enough to have many more stories written about him as he ages ..
my advice ..get the book and treasure the reading

The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice & Virtue—more like The Gentleman’s Guide to Breaking my Heart One Page at a Time by Mackenzi Lee. Given it might not be a catchy title as TGGTVV, but it be rather apt, and all true.

With a cast like Monty, Percy, & Felicity, it really is not possible to not fall in love with this book. The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice & Virtue is filled with adventure, heart and resilience. Recently, I was having a conversation with a TGGTVV reader, she responded with something that read, “I’m loving it, it took a dark turn that I wasn’t expecting.” It got me thinking on the journey, and the story, and my expectations and the delivery, and until I’m sat here writing this review…it hit me.

This story is different to what I was expecting, but in the ways that make this story so successful, that makes it one of the best reads I had this year. See, TGGTVV isn’t merely about a Grant Tour, it isn’t about Monty and his antics. Rather it talks about how privileged Monty is in someways. I want to point out that there is TW for parental abuse, racial slurs, homophobia and biphobia, epilepsy, abelism, and if I’m missing anything let me know. All of this is unpacked within the novel, and I’m living for the days book unpack all the problematic things in reality. See before when an author wrote homophobia it wouldn’t be unpacked, it wouldn’t get called out within the text, it would just be a thing that happened, because “that’s real life,” because that’s not what the author believes, but what the character believes like what kind of BS.

No, TGGTVV unpacks a lot of the privileged way that Monty thinks—in respect of Percy, and Felicity, in women, in the world. I wish I could touch up on everything, but I just want everyone to read it and fall in love with the story and it’s characters. I can say with 100 % certainty that I love Percy, Monty & Felicity. That throughout the book I was in 110% in, rooting for them all, in a wild ride that I almost didn’t want to end.

Percy and Monty are basically ship goals (I’m trying not to make ship puns here, guy!) This are two are the epitome of Tumblr Post OTP #1 of those two are so in love that everyone knows it except them two. I love the slow burn. GIVE ME THE SLOW BURN, I say. I love how in love Monty is, and it’s like ….sooooo……goood. Monty is hilarious, and boy, would I be friends with him just go get into the trouble he always finds himself in. AND PERCY MY CINNAMON, TOO PURE FOR THIS WORLD. What else can I say, but if anyone or anything hurts him I WILL go all Taken-on-their-butt?

AND FREAKING FELICITY. Can I get a-women? This girl one hell of a badass. She’s the bookworm all of us are? Ready to kick butt, and save everyone. And she doesn’t put up with Monty’s shenanigans.

Also. P I R A T E S. Hell to the yes.

Hell to the yes on all of this. HELL TO THE YES GO BUY THIS BOOK. now.

I actually picked up THE GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE TO VICE AND VIRTUE in hardcover at my local bookstore because a friend recommended it. I'm so glad I did. It's highly entertaining. It's set in the early 19th century with the POV character and his best friend (and sister and tutor, sadly for him) making the Grand Tour. It's funny and tense and we see the MC being a jerk and then struggling to change in response to events. Plot, character, setting, and theme are all so well done.

I loved this book so much. It was such a fun read but, at the same time, the plot was fairly complex and the characters had so much depth. Monty running naked through the gardens of Versailles is a picture I won't soon forget, and I imagine a young Hugh Grant in my mind. This book needs to become a movie soon! I cannot wait for Petticoats.

I feel like this book repeatedly murdered me and alchemically raised me from the dead, because let’s be honest, it pretty much took over my life for a few days. It’s fun and smart and well-written and thoughtful and diverse and I just wish I had a physical copy so I could hug it because my heart feels so warm and full right now thinking about these characters and their stories.

I went into this with pretty high expectations—considering the hype it got from ALL of my friends—and I was not disappointed. The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue follows the story of Henry (“Monty”) Montague, his best friend (and secret crush) Percy Newton, and his younger sister Felicity. The three teenagers set off on a Grand Tour of Europe, which is basically the eighteenth-century equivalent of rich kids taking a gap year before college to go backpacking. In theory, they’re meant to be having a life-changing educational and cultural experience…but in reality, there’s a lot of drinking and poor life-decision-making. As you might imagine, the characters—well, mostly Monty—manage to get themselves into a series of misadventures and nearly cause an international incident, all the while learning more about themselves and each other AND having some really top-notch and honest conversations about gender, disability, and sexuality!!!!!!!

Content warnings for: alcoholism, parental abuse, homophobia, racism, ableism, and epilepsy.

THE CHARACTERS

I love these three fictional humans with all of my alchemically dead heart, so this section will be a largely incoherent collection of some of my thoughts on them:

Monty
- obnoxious, but I love him anyway
- “I’m unencumbered with excessive stature” is my new favorite euphemism for “I’m short.”
- has cute dimples and is not afraid to use them
- gets called out by his sister and friend for being incredibly ignorant of his privileged whiteness, maleness, and wealth
- despite his privilege, the struggles he faces with abuse, PTSD, and homophobia are not downplayed: the book makes a point of showing that nobody’s suffering is invalid

Percy
- is so relentlessly kind and thoughtful that he deserves all of the hugs in the world
- has hands that are described as the human equivalent of puppy paws so if that doesn’t prove how soft and nice he is idk what does
- is a music nerd
- lives with epilepsy, but his illness does not define him or have to prevent him from having a good life
- he's nice but that doesn't mean he lets people walk all over him or let his friends get away with saying offensive/problematic stuff

Felicity
- pretends to read smut at the breakfast table, iconic
- also reads pretty much everywhere, relatable
- sews her own wounds shut with no anesthetics and no complaints
- is only fifteen but has her life together way more than I ever will
- grabs eighteenth-century gender norms by the throat and tells them to gtfo

THE PLOT/SETTINGS

I absolutely LOVE books that combine travel and history, and I was especially excited to see how some of the cities I’ve personally visited were represented in eighteenth-century historical fiction. The plot intertwined with all of the different locations in fun and interesting ways, and ended up being much more intriguing and mysterious than I’d expected. There were a few moments around the middle of the book where it seemed to drag a bit (this may have also been a side effect of the reading slump I was in at the time), but the characters still held my interest, and it wasn’t long before it picked back up again.

THE ROMANCE

Alright, if any of you know anything about me, you know that I am incredibly picky about romance. I cannot stand poorly developed or overly cheesy relationships or *shudders* angsty love triangles, so you know when I say I ship it the romance has to be pretty amazing.

Percy and Monty’s relationship is basically a collection of so many romantic tropes (slow burn best friends to lovers, secretly in love the whole time, charming playboy in love with quiet friend, etc.) but they’re all SO well done. I don’t think I can really elaborate further without being spoiler-y and/or devolving into a puddle of feelings.

THE THEMES AND DIVERSITY

One of this book’s greatest strengths is how well it portrays characters grappling with both their own and other people’s discrimination and biases. Monty struggles to understand Percy’s illness, the racial discrimination he experiences, and how to support his friend. Felicity strives to better comprehend Monty’s sexuality, and recognize that his attractions to both men and women are not something he can control. Both of the boys overlook the ways in which Felicity is barred from having a traditional education or professional career on account of her gender. All of these characters screw up sometimes. They say things that are offensive or insensitive, and they lack the words or knowledge to easily articulate their own identities and situations. But they also learn from these mistakes. They never justify the discriminatory systems in place in their society, and they overcome their own prejudices to arrive at a place of mutual understanding and support. This is a rare historical fiction book about the people who are so often erased in both this genre and real-life historical accounts and narratives. It’s a reminder that LGBTQ+, disabled, and POC people have always existed, and their stories have always been worthy of telling.

THE WRITING

I usually feel like a book’s writing has specific strengths, certain aspects of the story that it feels better suited for—but in this book it’s fantastically versatile. Lee’s writing style has an authentic-feeling voice, dialogue that will make you both laugh and cry, and a sprinkling of beautiful descriptions that are powerful and sincere. I absolutely adored this book, and I can’t wait to read more from her in the future.

THIS BOOK. This book was an absolute delight, and a real breath of fresh air in the world of YA historical fiction. It pulled me in straight from the beginning and KEPT me in-- I read the whole thing in about 24 hours and enjoyed each and every minute of it. Although the plot was a little nonsensical at times, I enjoyed the fast pace, and I loved the characters. Despite being, well, "a scoundrel", Monty was a delightful narrator. I also adored Felicity (and I'm 100% ecstatic that she's getting her own book.) If I had one complaint about the book, it would be that Percy was a little underdeveloped. He had the potential to be a super interesting character, but he lacked depth-- I swear he didn't do anything wrong/make a mistake once in the entire book, and the inhuman perfection made his character a little less interesting than I would have liked. But overall, I loved GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE and I can't wait to read the Felicity-centric followup <3

I book this book thinking it'd be a light read with some fun and mayhem. It was a good book, with an interesting storyline but it wasn't really light. There were some interesting themes and storylines running through it that kept it from being light but did make me want to read more.

Funny, heartwarming, exciting... this book really has it all. The characters just leap off the page, and the story keeps you pinned to your seat from the beginning. This is one of the few books that has actually made me laugh out loud. Despite the humour, it's also heartbreaking at times and I just fell in love with the characters.
I definitely recommend it for a fun read, with excellent dialogue and wonderful characters!

I loved this book. Loved. It is funny, with witty dialogue and characters that I wish were real. The Gentleman's Guide is filled with action and adventure and gave me a history lesson the way I like it: wrapped up inside a great story. I'd also like to mention that it's a terrific crush/love story; Mackenzi Lee is great at writing longing, and I found myself rooting for friendship to blossom into more, and for the happy ending they all deserve. The book surpassed all of my expectations. A must read, LGBTQ or straight.

Wow wow wow wow wow wow wow! One of my favorite reads of the year. Monty's voice is hysterical, and the antics he finds himself in throughout his Grand Tour had me cracking up, cringing, and at times, bawling. I can't say enough how much I enjoyed the way the feelings and love develop between Monty and Percy. Must read!

There's a lot of hype surrounding TGGTVAV, specifically with the LGBTQIA representation. The mc is bisexual and the love interest is gay (and biracial. The sister may also be asexual (representation for me, yay!). However, I'm not going to ignore the fact that Monty is a bit of a promiscuous rascal. Because of this, the representation for bisexuality may be harmful. What I mean is... there are some people who don't really understand what bisexuality means. For instance, I have read a common misconception about bisexuals being attracted to everyone and everything. I know the author isn't intending to write something that is harmful that promotes this type of thinking. However, someone might find this very offending because the character, Monty, you notice him flirting with almost everyone. The reader reads his pov and most of the time, he talks about being attracted to different people (both sexes) by talking about their features. I think the humorous pov helped, and it completely disguises/hides the harmful trope made by less open-minded people. So it's not entirely noticeable until you actually think about it. Well, I had so much time to think about it! I've had this ARC since May and I finished it in July!

Percy is a bit of a dull character for me. He's always there for Monty and if it weren't for his secret, he wouldn't be that interesting. I'm still trying to figure out what his personality is like. Is he the quiet one? the shy type? He seems sensible. But what else? What more can we learn about Percy? His secret was also bad news, so that pretty much puts a damper in the story. Fortunately, the history behind that secret and what it entails is historically accurate. What I loved about this book is the historical concepts! I definitely enjoyed reading about them at the very end of the novel.

Felicity was such a joy to read! I love how she's a book nerd just like we all are in this website. I don't think it's believable that she was able to spend time learning about medicine in her spare time, without anyone knowing about it. I know she goes to school, but they teach women household chores or how to be a proper. I don't think medicine counts. I'm not really sure, correct me if I'm wrong. I love history but I certainly am not a history buff.

The book was very funny and entertaining even before I reached the 50% mark. It's just unfortunate that all the fun and excitement diminishes by page 274ish? I have the ARC, so I'm not really sure where it is in the FC. It's around the time when a lot of crazy stuff went down with the Duke and now Monty along with Percy and Felicity are on a wild adventure. There was a lot of trips and running + chasing, kind of like a heist (but not really). Not only are these characters touring across Europe but other crazy stuff happened along the way.

I would recommend this despite having the reading slump. I know a lot of people actually enjoyed reading the book.

This book is everything I needed and wanted it to be! I loved Lee's This Monstrous Thing, so I'd been looking forward to this for forever, and it didn't disappoint one little bit. It's abso-bloody-lutely FANTASTIC, and I laughed and cried and cheered and gasped! It's so good.

It has a wonderfully fun and engaging voice with very loveable characters. The story itself bored me a little, and I found myself skimming a few parts. If you're interested, I do recommend it. It just didn't completely steal my heart in every way.

"The great tragic love story of Percy and me is neither great nor truly a love story, and is tragic only for its single-sidedness."

I don't have the words to summarize how much I abso-bloody-lutely LOVED this book.
This book is so much fun to read. As soon as i picked it up, i couldn't put it down. Everything was beyond perfect. I honestly believe everyone should give this book a chance.

So much fun. It took me awhile to get started, I still feel it ran a little long, but once I got a feel for the writing style I adored all the crazy historical nods and send ups of a proper grand tour with a more colorful view on life from that period than we usually see in historical fiction. I love his sister, and can't wait to see how this is going to unfold in the sequel!

You have to read this book. It's funny and touching and oh my god I couldn't put it down. This is an adventure you'll never forget. The dialogue is so real and the story is easy to follow and is the perfect setting for the characters. And don't even get me started on this cast of characters who are just a lovely little trio it could kill me.

I expected to enjoy this book I ended up loving it! The narrator is so witty and charming, you couldn't help but loving him. I caught myself giggling out loud so many times. There was also quite a bit more action than I had been expecting.

Fun and cute read that I've been recommending to everyone.

I absolutely loved the synopsis and cover for this book and I can't believe it took me so long to read it.

Monty and Percy are absolutely delightful. I loved their slow burn romance and could have read a million more pages of their flirting and kissing. Felicity was so so so much fun and I can't express my excitement at her getting her own book.

Plot wise, the story takes off right from the start and doesn't let up until the very end. There are highwaymen and pirates and parties and explosions and tombs and alchemy and jails and I was entertained the entire book. The ending was completely satisfying and left me wanting more. Even after reading 500+ pages.

**Huge thanks to Katherine Tegen Books for providing the arc free of charge**

What a great read! Monty, Percy and Felicity have just about everything happen to them as they rush about in 18th century Europe. Monty is all teenage angst and self-loathing, making a futile attempt to distract himself from loving Percy madly. Percy is goodness personified in a multi-cultural package, with a wicked sense of humor to boot. Who could blame Monty for being in love? Felicity is the misunderstood younger sister, who seems ripe for further stories and is trying to define herself outside traditional female roles. The plot moves very well and the writing is really top notch. Looking forward to more adventures.

I found out about The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue through a YouTube video. I got it was immediately hooked. It's action packed, enjoyable and relatable chatacters. full of emotion and such a fun read. The only thing I didn't care for is I felt the ending was a bit ambigious. It wrapped up well but I need more.

You won't be disappointed. Fancy bisexual English lord who is a bitnof a dumpster fire, alchemical cure alls, vengeful french dukes, pirates, and a really satisfying slow burn romance? What more could you want?

Oh my heart. This book was like how you feel after a rollercoaster ride. I was exhilarated, breathless and dying for more. I couldn't have been more charmed by Monty and Percy and Felicity. I want to read 10 more books about them if possible. Thank you McKenzi Lee for an incredible story and one that I will be able to keep enjoying for a long time coming.

It was delightful! The author did a great job of showing how incredibly difficult it would be to be gay, female, or a person of color in the eighteenth century. Not that it's always a picnic now, mind you, but Felicity, Percy, and Monty had a much harder time of it. Even so, the exciting plot and Monty's snarky, humorous narrative voice made this a really fun read!

This book is three things all at once:

1) A sweet love story that doesn’t treat you like an idiot.
2) A fun historical setting with a clear-eyed view of the downsides of the time period.
3) A romping, edge of your seat adventure novel.

Highly recommend!

This book is quite a ride and never stops! There is a new twist that keeps the pace steady and and the adventure rolling. Also this book does not solely rely on the plot to carry it forward. There is an intriguing cast of characters that each is a book unto themselves. But Monty is our flawed hero with Felicity his quite and mysterious sister, and his conflicted friend Percy. Very well written and an excellent read.

I’m usually not a fan of historical books, even fictional ones, but this one was absolutely fantastic. The perfect blend of comedy and emotion and realism serves to set this novel apart from the rest. I’m greeting looking forward to more from this author.

I got this book in my owlcrate subscription. It is well written and I loved the characters. I wish some parts were elaborated and gave a bit more detail. Overall it was a great book and I would recommend it!