She Who Remembers

While vacationing in Sedona, Az I went to find an historical fiction to connect me to the ancient inhabitants I was learning about in this incredible area.

This book is not the connection I'd hoped for. While the physical environs were well researched and covered in her book, for me Shuler's character's were unbelievable and simplistic. The story was not interesting and I found myself easily distracted while reading. I finished it mostly because I was on vacation with few other options.

Based on the many great reviews here, I ordered all 3 books in this trilogy but now have no real interest in picking up the other 2.

Well, I've read the whole series 3 times now. I was only 13 the first time I read it, so it was much more interesting that time. But as I get older, I look at it as an interesting diversian. It was the first book of this genre I ever read, and I should say, that I am now addicted. I then went on to Clan of the Cave Bear, etc...

I agree somewhat with a previous reviewer, as I am also Wiccan, I found the witchcraft issue offensive. But I also realize that, although it seems offensive, it is a very accurate description of the beliefs of that time. Also, they had a different opinion of what made a "witch." As a Wiccan, we are more closely in tune with their Holy men and woman, not the "witches" witches to them, were evil spirits, and people, who seeked only to harm people, and gain for themselves, whereas Wiccans today, and the Holy men and woman of yesterday, seek to help people. Do what thou will but harm None.

This aside, let's get to the book itself.

Although I find the story very entertaining, Kwani's love life does indeed get very boring. It's just one man after another. And the issue about a Viking of that time is a little far fetched. But we call this genre Fiction for a reason.

I do find Shuler's theory on Kokepelli very interesting though. For the reason that the Anazasi, and similar tribes, did worship a Fertillity God... he was painted as a man with a flute, sometimes his penis was the flute. And so, she incorperated this into the story. I find the religion a little odd though, because the Anazasi seem to have worshipped this Kokepelli, and then it looks as though they converted to the Katchina's. Shuler mentions neither as a God/s. So what are they worshipping?

Actually, if someone is looking for a very good depiction of the Anazasi, I suggest Kathleen and Michael O'Neal Gear's books People of the Silence... very good indeed, and The Anazasi Mystery Series, also by them. They are historians and archaeologists, I find their books much more accurate, also they add a certain degree of speculation to get you thinking.

But in the end, She Who Remembers is an interesting story, losely based on a real artifact, the necklace, and it is an entertaining light read... especially for those with no interest in complete accuracy, only a fun book. Although, the last of the series Let the drum Speak, is not very good at all. A very weak ending to an otherwise, good story. I believe any good plot ended when a main male character dies... it's all down hill from there. So She Who Remembers, and the sequel Voice of the Eagle are interesting and fun, but the last is really very boring. I wonder why so many authors of this genre end their series with a story about the original characters children? It seems like a very weak way to wrap it up to me.

I grew up in the southwest and have been to Chaco and Mesa Verde and many of the pueblos.The homes still bear the marks on wood and stone of the tools of those who lived there. It is intriguing to imagine how they interacted with themselves and their surroundings. A good read

I love to read. I just didn't love reading this. I didn't make it past chapter seven, if I even made it that far. I love Native American culture and thought this book would be interesting and entertaining. I didn't particularly care for any of the characters. Some of the descriptions were just absolutely ridiculous. I wanted a book that had a compelling story about Native Americans, I did not want a non-accurate story and romance novel. I returned it without finishing it. I read a lot, this is the first book that I decided not to finish and return. I had the audiobook as well and was very put off by the narrator's voice. It sounded as if she over used some editing program and only read one sentence at a time. When it first started I thought that it was a computer reading the story. It just wasn't good.

well written, edited almost to perfection, great story line. also brilliantly interesting. loved this book. it is very long, but kept my interest. with a magnificent heroine, who goes through too much to be true, it is a captivating story.

In this book, Kwani is driven from her tribe because of her blue eyes, inherited from a Norse ancestor. I found the details of her journey with the legendary Kokopeli to be interesting in this first book. It ended in such a way that I wanted to read Book Two. Now ask me how I felt at the end of Book Two . . . .

Linda Lay Shuler is a storyteller beyond comparison. The imagery is rich. The characters are well defined. The historical research is flawless. Kwani is an amazingly real character. She has such a passion for life and a will to survive that beats all odds, yet she is so warm and vulnerable. The characters feel like people you may have known and the story like one you heard long ago. It is a truly unforgettable story.

From the start, I was hooked. Every emotion possible. Also, after reading all 3 books, I noticed similarities to todays way of life. Have to admit that I have gone through withdrawals after finishing the books. I wanted more.

I gave this book a five star rating because it is a very fascinating book. I could easily identify with Kwani and the descriptions of the country and the people made me believe they could be real. I believe part of this reason is because I'm a very spiritual person and I believe in meditation and spiritual quests. Although I don't believe everything I read, this author makes fiction believable. I would recommend this book to adults with open minds because of the sexuality, which is necessary to the book and the story line, but is not common in our time and which some people might find offensive.

Just down right good reading. The territory the people lived,worked,played,loved,,hunted were interesting. Was glad to finds out the exact location it was taken place. Insight to the Times were astonishing. Loved the book. Looking forward to the next.

She Who Remembers, by Linda Lay Shuler, was a fabulous book on the lifestyles of Native Americans. Her use of imagery to portray the endless landscape of the plains adds a mystical allure to the story. The extensive research that went into the story was clear in Shuler's discription of the people and their lifestyles. The story of Kwani is moving, adventurous, and on the edge of your seat exciting. The story is romantic in parts and sad in others. If you do not believe in ancient magic and multiple Gods, you will by the end. Shuler's choice of diction to continually refer to the sun as sunfather and the moon as moonwoman etc., allows the reader to feel like they are actually inside of the story with the other characters. She portrays human instinct with conflict and lust. She proves that the pilgrims were not the first to create witches to solve why death and drought come upon a community. She Who Remembers is the number one novel on Americas prehistory.

This is one of those books you just can't put down because you just gotta see what's going to happen next. By looking at her references in the back, I can tell Shuler did a lot of research for this book. Although many will say, that this book is not historically accurate. So who cares? We all need a little fantasy and imagination in our lives. What is the definition of fiction anyway? I would descibe this book as a mix of a historical novel that reads as a romance novel, a suspense novel, and even an erotic novel at times. This book is a must read. Actually, I just bought the second book today and plan on reading all three in the series.

Our neighborhood bar offers a free book exchange. We took it because of the comment by Jane Auel.(My husband loved her books.) I think "She Who Remembers" is a better story than the Clan books. The action takes place in 13th century America and creates a tale about the elusive Anasazi's. The story blends archeological data and Ameriand legend. It is action packed and a quick read. It hardly stops for a breath. I would reccommend it to any reader who enjoyed "Mists of Avalon.

Having traveled through Colorado and New Mexico and having lived in Arizona, Ms Shuler brought back many memories of those days when we explored the sites of the cliff dwellers. She brought it to life and I was transported back in time. What a wonderful read....can't wait to read the next two books in this trilogy!!

I love this book. I read it long ago when I was younger and have always been interested in the Indians and the Cliff Dwelling Indians. The story of She Who Remembers held my interest. I read the book in about 3 to 4 nights of reading before bed.

I gave this book a five star rating because it is a very fascinating book. I could easily identify with Kwani and the descriptions of the country and the people made me believe they could be real. I believe part of this reason is because I'm a very spiritual person and I believe in meditation and spiritual quests. Although I don't believe everything I read, this author makes fiction believable. I would recommend this book to adults with open minds because of the sexuality, which is necessary to the book and the story line, but is not common in our time and which some people might find offensive.

Just down right good reading. The territory the people lived,worked,played,loved,,hunted were interesting. Was glad to finds out the exact location it was taken place. Insight to the Times were astonishing. Loved the book. Looking forward to the next.

She Who Remembers, by Linda Lay Shuler, was a fabulous book on the lifestyles of Native Americans. Her use of imagery to portray the endless landscape of the plains adds a mystical allure to the story. The extensive research that went into the story was clear in Shuler's discription of the people and their lifestyles. The story of Kwani is moving, adventurous, and on the edge of your seat exciting. The story is romantic in parts and sad in others. If you do not believe in ancient magic and multiple Gods, you will by the end. Shuler's choice of diction to continually refer to the sun as sunfather and the moon as moonwoman etc., allows the reader to feel like they are actually inside of the story with the other characters. She portrays human instinct with conflict and lust. She proves that the pilgrims were not the first to create witches to solve why death and drought come upon a community. She Who Remembers is the number one novel on Americas prehistory.

This is one of those books you just can't put down because you just gotta see what's going to happen next. By looking at her references in the back, I can tell Shuler did a lot of research for this book. Although many will say, that this book is not historically accurate. So who cares? We all need a little fantasy and imagination in our lives. What is the definition of fiction anyway? I would descibe this book as a mix of a historical novel that reads as a romance novel, a suspense novel, and even an erotic novel at times. This book is a must read. Actually, I just bought the second book today and plan on reading all three in the series.

Our neighborhood bar offers a free book exchange. We took it because of the comment by Jane Auel.(My husband loved her books.) I think "She Who Remembers" is a better story than the Clan books. The action takes place in 13th century America and creates a tale about the elusive Anasazi's. The story blends archeological data and Ameriand legend. It is action packed and a quick read. It hardly stops for a breath. I would reccommend it to any reader who enjoyed "Mists of Avalon.

Having traveled through Colorado and New Mexico and having lived in Arizona, Ms Shuler brought back many memories of those days when we explored the sites of the cliff dwellers. She brought it to life and I was transported back in time. What a wonderful read....can't wait to read the next two books in this trilogy!!

I love this book. I read it long ago when I was younger and have always been interested in the Indians and the Cliff Dwelling Indians. The story of She Who Remembers held my interest. I read the book in about 3 to 4 nights of reading before bed.

The story is well written and very detailed in the lives of the Indian tribes in the southwestern part of the country. You find yourself walking step by step with her in the unfolding story of ONE WHO REMEMBERS.

I am in the middle of the second book in this trilogy and don't want to put it down. There is so much Indian lore in this book and the story of Kwani is a lesson about respect, loyalty and family. Love the adventure!

I read this book years ago but had forgotten much of it. As an avid fan of historical fiction, I enjoyed the glimpse back into the culture of early native Americans. I would recommend this book to anyone who shares these interests. Some parts may be a little graphic for some readers, but are essential to the plot. There are two more books after this one that continue the story of Kwani. Great read. Dorinda

Mrs. Shuler is in a class by herself, she is the only author that I know of that received a nod from Mrs. Auel. This book is beautiful, filled with very colorfull characters and a gripping plot and the most wonderfull backdrop, the American Southwest.(I have been out there and it is as Mrs. Shuler writes it, the sky does go on forever!)

This book She Who Remembers drew me into the lives of the characters right away. I love the history lessons and the beautiful way the author describes the clothing, tools, customs, beliefs, rituals and more. You will love the characters and their histories and backgrounds well done Linda

She Who Remembers is a beautifully written and very touching novel that will bring tears to your eyes. Kwani will touch your heart like you never thought possible. Her tribe's cruel rejection of her because she was different proves that prejudice has existed throughout time and the pain it causes is always the same. Her unexpected friendship and love for a tribal medicine man also proves that there is hope in even the bleakest times. Contained within Kwani's story is also a very entertaining history lesson about the earliest beginnings of our country and it's people. Perhaps after reading this wonderful story we will realize how far we have strayed from mother nature and our own history. There is something to be learned from Kwani and her people, and that will make for a book you can't put down until you have turned the last page and leave you wishing for more

strength comes in many ways. the individual portraited in this novel had strength beyond any I would have. Have read much about the Indians over the years and feel this was a good reflection of what I have read.

I read this book some time ago.... after I finished Jean Auel's books... I found these three by Linda Lay Shuler.. I introduced these books to my boyfriend few days ago and I think he will like it because he enjoyed reading Jean Auel's books and it was him who got me into reading Auel's books... =) all in all, these three books are a must read :)

I've always enjoyed learning about Native American life, but I hesitated at the start of this book, not thinking I would enjoy this long of a book on Native American historical fiction. I quickly learned how wrong I was. This book is fantasic. There is always something going on, not a boring telling of Native American life, but a constant adventure through the lives of various tribes and a brilliant development of special women and men of early American life. It gives an excellent telling of the hierarchy of the clans. I could not put this book down and so look forward to reading the two sequels.

I really enjoyed this book. I tend to enjoy historical fiction and this work is a lovely treatment of pre-Colombian culture. It kept me engaged enough so that I went on the read the other two books in the trilogy.

Took you back in time. To people and histories long ago forgotten. In fact NO name really exists except for what the elders passed down as "the aceint ones" h. I highly recommend this book . You won't put it down .

I really enjoyed this book that I read it three times. It was very primitive and how one can survive in a world like that interests me. Very vivid and you can feel what the main character is also feeling and seeing. Loved it!!. I also enjoyed the two books folowing this one but I found I enjoyed the first one in this series to be my favorite.

Interesting book, in line with "Hanta Yo" and "Clan of the Cave Bear." I was put off, though, by a number of anachronisms (tumble weed, wild boar, for example) and some very poor editing (horded?!). Good read nonetheless.

Ms. Shuler did awesome research into the Anasazi and Pueblo cultures! Living on the Navajo Reservation in Arizona I have heard some of these tells from Navajo and Hopi friends. I have visited Mesa Verde and Chaco Canyon and she has made the people of ancient times live and breathe.

i loved this book! linda lay shuler happens to be one of my favorite authors. after you read *she who remembers* which i might also add, you will not be able to put down. you will HAVE to go on to read the next 2 in the series, which are,
*voice of the eagle*, and then onto, *let the drum speak*
these are 3 of the best historical novels i have ever had the pleasure of reading. i guarantee you will not be able to put any of them down, once you begin to read them. you will fall in love with them!
pinkyvi

Read this book when I was younger and fell in love! Draws you into the story and won't let you go. I am so excites to find it today cause I have the paperback original book and its a little in pieces cause of how I read it time after time.

This book has to be by far the best romance novel I have ever read. From the very first chapter it captures the imagination and holds it firmly to the very end. The storyline flowed so precise that I was able to feel every emotion that the main character (Kwani) endured. I felt as if I were right there with her experiencing every encounter that she was forced to face. This novel is definitely one that I strongly recommend to all readers.

I just finished She Who Remembers and the sequel to it and thought they were amazing. I can't wait to get the third book and read about Antelopes story. What a great family to read about - I promise you won't be sorry!

I have read this book three times and loved it each time. It is a book that enchants you and takes to a totally different time and place. This is my favorite book, shuler is a great writer. The 2nd and 3rd book are also good but she who remembers is the best.

This was one of the best books I've ever read. Linda Lay Shuler's idea of what the American southwest must have been like was magnificant. The book was very well researched, surprising, funny, and sad. The end of the book left you thristing for more, yet satisfied. I was very impressed. I'd definately recommend this book to anyone.

Thoroughly enjoyed this book and the other 2 in the series. I am a fan of the clan of the cavebear series, and found this to be along similiar lines. This story has many different elements to it; theres romance, mystery, violence, suspense and so much more...... Give this book a try, if you like historical books you'll love it

Dumped me out of suspension of disbelief immediately. If you have a population entirely brown eyed, and one has a child with a blue eyed person, you do NOT get blue eyes in the first generation, blue is recessive.

This book was truly one of the best books i have read. it rivals The clan of the cave bear series, which i thought wasn't possible! The love story, suspense, and drama captivated me, and I honestly couldn't put it down. if you're looking for a good novel, definately pick this one up.

I am so glad that I had a chance to read all 3 books. I found them wonderful and I couldn't put them down. It put me back in time of what it may have been. I felt I could have been part of this past. Thank-you for a great time of reading. Margaret Rowe

She Who Remembers is a beautifully written and very touching novel that will bring tears to your eyes. Kwani will touch your heart like you never thought possible. Her tribe's cruel rejection of her because she was different proves that prejudice has existed throughout time and the pain it causes is always the same. Her unexpected friendship and love for a tribal medicine man also proves that there is hope in even the bleakest times. Contained within Kwani's story is also a very entertaining history lesson about the earliest beginnings of our country and it's people. Perhaps after reading this wonderful story we will realize how far we have strayed from mother nature and our own history. There is something to be learned from Kwani and her people, and that will make for a book you can't put down until you have turned the last page and leave you wishing for more

I purchased this trilogy because it seemed interesting and love books that are written as a series. I have never read books about American Indian History. I found it not only interesting but very well written. I was invited into an unfamiliar world and loved it. Cant wait to continue the journey in Book 2.